1.1 The UK regulatory architecture: FSMA, the FCA, the PRA, HMT and the BoE
▼From the FSA to the FCA and PRA syllabus 1.1.1
The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA) came into effect in 2001. It swept away a patchwork of self-regulatory organisations and put a single statutory regulator, the Financial Services Authority (FSA), in charge of both prudential and conduct regulation. The FSA shared oversight with the Bank of England and HM Treasury in a "tripartite" system.
After the 2007-08 crisis the Chancellor ordered a review. That led to the Financial Services Act 2012 (in effect 2013), which created three bodies: the Financial Policy Committee (FPC), the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA).
The Financial Services Act 2021 is the post-Brexit amending Act. Four things to recall from it:
- the Investment Firms Prudential Regime (IFPR) arrived in January 2022 for MiFID investment firms not regulated by the PRA - lighter than the CRR/CRD regime, refocused on the harm a firm could do to consumers and markets;
- amendments touching UK MiFIR, the Overseas Funds Regime and the Gibraltar Authorisation Regime (market access);
- extra FCA powers to manage the wind-down of LIBOR and to extend the use of third-country benchmarks;
- the maximum sentence for criminal market abuse under UK MAR rose from seven to ten years.
The FPC and the Bank of England syllabus 1.1.2, 1.1.6
The FPC is a committee of the Bank of England with a statutory objective to protect and enhance the stability of the UK financial system. It identifies, monitors and acts on systemic risks, and can make recommendations to, and give directions to, the PRA and FCA.
The Bank of England (BoE) does everything a central bank does and is independent of government on monetary policy. It works through two areas:
| Area | What it means | Key detail |
|---|---|---|
| Monetary stability | Stable prices and confidence in the currency | Inflation target currently 2% (12-month CPI); the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) sets the base rate to meet it |
| Financial stability | Detecting and reducing threats to the whole financial system | The FPC and PRA operate here; BoE can act as lender of last resort in exceptional circumstances |
The BoE also supervises certain financial market infrastructures (FMIs): payment systems recognised by HM Treasury, central securities depositories (CSDs) and central counterparties (CCPs).
FCA versus PRA - who does what syllabus 1.1.3, 1.1.4
The FCA regulates the conduct of all financial services firms and is the prudential regulator of firms the PRA does not supervise (asset managers and investment firms, excluding banks and deposit-takers). The PRA (part of the BoE, acting through its Prudential Regulation Committee) regulates the safety and soundness of banks, building societies, credit unions, insurers and major investment firms. Firms supervised by both are dual-regulated.
| FCA | PRA | |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Markets work well; consumers get a fair deal | Stability - safety and soundness of firms |
| Covers | Conduct of all firms; prudential for non-PRA firms | Banks, building societies, credit unions, insurers, major investment firms |
| Also responsible for | FOS, PSR, the UK listing regime, unfair terms (CRA 2015) in consumer contracts; FSCS jointly with the PRA | Works with the BoE resolution unit on the special resolution regime (Banking Act 2009) |
| Funding | Fees from regulated firms | Fees from regulated firms |
The FCA is accountable to government through HM Treasury, which is in turn accountable to Parliament.
HM Treasury and the FCA syllabus 1.1.5
HM Treasury runs public finance and economic policy and oversees financial services; the FCA reports directly to it. The Treasury:
- appoints the FCA board and chairman and can dismiss board members;
- receives the FCA annual report (how it discharged its functions and met its objectives), accompanied by a report from the FCA non-executive directors, and lays it before Parliament;
- can commission independent reviews of the FCA, limited to the economy, efficiency and effectiveness of its use of resources;
- can, through Parliament, change the nature of the FCA role.
1.2 FCA and PRA objectives, powers and the Principles of Good Regulation
▼The FCA objectives syllabus 1.1.13
The FCA has one strategic objective - to ensure that relevant markets function well - supported by three operational objectives:
| Objective | Essence | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Consumer protection | An appropriate degree of protection | Does not mean preventing every loss; consumers should take responsibility for their decisions |
| Integrity | Protect and enhance the integrity of the UK financial system | Covers soundness/resilience, not being used for financial crime, freedom from market abuse, orderly markets and transparent price formation |
| Competition | Promote effective competition in consumers' interests | Ease of switching, ease of entry for new firms, innovation, access |
Since the Financial Services and Markets Act 2023 (provisions in force from 29 August 2023), both the FCA and the PRA also have a secondary objective: to help the UK economy stay internationally competitive and grow over the medium to long term, in line with international standards. It only operates in support of the existing objectives - it does not override them.
Under Part 10 of FSMA the FCA can make legally binding rules for authorised firms, provided they appear necessary or expedient to advance an operational objective. The FCA also oversees the professional bodies that supervise AML compliance through OPBAS.
The PRA objectives and supervisory style syllabus 1.1.14
The PRA has three statutory objectives:
- a general objective to promote the safety and soundness of the firms it regulates;
- an insurance objective - contribute to securing an appropriate degree of protection for policyholders;
- a secondary objective to facilitate effective competition (plus, since FSMA 2023, the international competitiveness objective described above).
Its style has three characteristics: judgement-based, forward-looking (intervening early) and focused on the firms and issues posing the greatest risk to stability and policyholders. In forming a judgement it assesses gross risk (impact on the system plus external and business-model risk), then overlays mitigating factors to reach net risk. The PRA prefers to secure ex ante remedial action, but can impose financial penalties and publish censures.
FCA powers - product intervention, promotions, disciplinary publicity syllabus 1.1.3, 1.1.13
Core FSMA powers (shared in general form by the PRA for the firms it authorises): authorisation (Part 4A permission), supervision, discipline and sanctions, and enforcement aiming at credible deterrence. The FCA additionally holds three powers from the Financial Services Act 2012:
| Power | What it lets the FCA do | Detail to remember |
|---|---|---|
| Temporary product intervention | Make temporary rules banning or restricting a product causing (or likely to cause) consumer problems | Up to 12 months. Aimed at earlier intervention; aimed at UK-sold products even when the provider is overseas if sold by UK intermediaries |
| Banning financial promotions | Direct that a misleading promotion be withdrawn immediately | Targets the promotion, not the firm; firm may make representations; FCA then confirms, amends or revokes and publishes |
| Publicising disciplinary action | Announce that it has started action, publishing a warning notice | Must consult the recipient before publishing |
The eight Principles of Good Regulation syllabus 1.1.13
The regulators must have regard to eight principles when carrying out their functions:
- Efficiency and economy in use of resources (Treasury can commission value-for-money reviews);
- Proportionality - burdens proportionate to expected benefits, tested with cost-benefit analysis;
- Sustainable growth of the UK economy in the medium or long term;
- Consumer responsibility - consumers take responsibility for their decisions;
- Senior management responsibility - senior management is responsible for the firm's activities and compliance, with clear allocation of responsibilities;
- Recognising differences between the businesses of different regulated persons;
- Openness and disclosure - publishing (or requiring publication of) relevant information about regulated persons;
- Transparency - exercising functions as transparently as possible.
How the FCA is held to account syllabus 1.1.13
Five accountability levers: the annual report to HM Treasury (scrutinised by Parliamentary committees); National Audit Office audit (which the Commons Public Accounts Committee can scrutinise); the obligation to show how its rules relate to its objectives; judicial review if it ignores or misreads its objectives; and a report to HM Treasury (laid before Parliament) after a serious regulatory failure.
1.3 Exchanges, clearing houses and trading venues
▼RIE, ROIE and DIE - the comparison the exam loves syllabus 1.1.7, 1.1.8
Most trading goes through established exchanges, so the FCA recognises and supervises them. The three labels are easy to mix up:
| RIE | ROIE | DIE | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Based | UK | Overseas (no UK head or registered office) | Overseas |
| FCA status | Recognised (FSMA s.290) and supervised | Recognised (FSMA s.292) and supervised | Not regulated or supervised by the FCA |
| Authorisation needed? | Exempt (s.285) from Part 4A for running the exchange | Exempt (s.285) likewise | Cannot undertake regulated activities in the UK |
| Test applied | Meets HMT's criteria (s.286) | FCA satisfied on equivalent investor protection, default procedures and co-operation (s.292) | Overseas standards compatible with FCA statutory objectives |
| Number | 5 | 32 (Dec 2024) | 29 |
The five UK RIEs: ICE Futures Europe; London Stock Exchange plc; London Metal Exchange Ltd; Aquis Stock Exchange Ltd; CBOE Europe Ltd. Examples of ROIEs include Deutsche Boerse AG, BOE Europe BV, CBOT and SIX Swiss Exchange AG. Examples of DIEs include AMEX, ASX, MGEX, NYSE, SGX, TSE and CISE. The only benefit of DIE designation is that under certain rules firms may treat DIE transactions like RIE transactions.
Recognised clearing houses (RCHs) syllabus 1.1.9
RCHs are recognised by order of the Bank of England (FSMA s.290) and are supervised by the BoE, not the FCA. Like RIEs they are exempt from Part 4A permission. A ROCH (recognised overseas clearing house) is recognised under s.292 and has no UK head or registered office.
| Recognised clearing house | Role to remember |
|---|---|
| LCH Ltd | CCP for Euronext.LIFFE, LME, ICE Futures and certain LSE trades |
| Euroclear UK & Ireland | Runs CREST for dematerialised settlement; a CSD, not a CCP |
| LME Clear Ltd | Launched 2015 for LME users |
| ICE Clear Europe Ltd | Clearing house and CCP for contracts on ICE Futures |
Designated professional bodies (DPBs) syllabus 1.1.10
Doing regulated business without authorisation is a crime, yet accountants or solicitors may give incidental investment advice. Under Part XX of FSMA such firms may carry on limited regulated business under the supervision of a DPB (for example the ICAEW) and are called exempt professional firms (EPFs), without separate FCA authorisation. DPB status covers ten bodies across five professions: accountants, solicitors, actuaries, chartered surveyors and licensed conveyancers.
Regulated markets, MTFs and OTFs syllabus 1.1.11, 1.1.12
In the FCA Handbook a regulated market is in essence a UK RIE (or a comparable overseas market dealing in comparable instruments), e.g. the LSE Main Market or Aquis Exchange Main Board. MiFID introduced the regulated activity of operating an MTF ("exchange lite": no listing process and no ability to change a security's regulatory status). MiFID II added the OTF.
| Feature | MTF | OTF |
|---|---|---|
| Instruments | Can include equities | No equities; bonds, structured finance products, emission allowances, derivatives |
| Operator discretion | Not permitted - non-discretionary rules | Permitted when placing/retracting an order, or when deciding not to match a client order |
| Matched principal trading | Operator cannot | Operator can (unless the derivative is subject to mandatory clearing under UK EMIR) |
| MiFID II investor protection (suitability, best execution, client order handling) | Not required of the operator | Required |
| Common ground | Both are multilateral systems that bring together third-party buying and selling interests to form a contract; clear trading rules; same transparency requirements as regulated markets |
MTFs can be run by an RIE (e.g. Turquoise, owned by the LSE), independents (e.g. LMAX Exchange) or investment banks (e.g. UBS).
1.4 Brexit and the direction of UK regulatory reform
▼Brexit: passports, UK MiFIR and assimilated law syllabus 1.1.15
After Brexit UK firms can no longer passport products or services into the EU, and EU firms cannot passport into the UK (they need a UK branch or subsidiary). From 1 January 2021 the onshored UK MiFIR (the EU Regulation 600/2014 as retained under the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018) applies to UK regulated firms; together with UK MiFID (implemented through FCA rules) it keeps UK firms on the same standards as EU firms for now. Over time the regimes will diverge. Retained EU law is now called assimilated law and stays in force until replaced.
The Wholesale Markets Review and FSMA 2023 syllabus 1.1.15
The Wholesale Markets Review asked how much retained EU market regulation should be adapted. Its stated objectives: uphold high regulatory standards; promote openness and competitiveness; deliver fair and proportionate regulation; support economic growth. The government said it would not change things for the sake of it. The FCA issued five consultation papers:
| # | Focus |
|---|---|
| 1 | Equities market |
| 2 | Trading venue perimeter |
| 3 | Framework for a UK consolidated tape for bonds |
| 4 | Transparency for bond and derivative markets (published December 2023) |
| 5 | Commodity derivatives |
The Financial Services and Markets Bill (2022) gave HM Treasury, the PRA and the FCA the powers to deliver the Review and the Future Regulatory Framework review. It received Royal Assent in June 2023 (as the Financial Services and Markets Act 2023), with some provisions in force from August 2023 and the rest from 1 January 2024. It begins the process of revoking retained EU financial services law and adds the growth and competitiveness secondary objective.
The Edinburgh Reforms syllabus 1.1.15
HM Treasury's December 2022 package. Key items: a new UK Short Selling Regime; a review of the SM&CR; an enhanced remit for the FCA and PRA; an independent investment research review; and reform of the Securitisation Regulation.
1.5 The general prohibition
▼The general prohibition (FSMA s.19) syllabus 1.2
No person (human or legal - companies, partnerships, trusts, unincorporated associations) may carry on a regulated activity in the UK, or purport to, unless authorised or exempt. Authorisation means a specific Part 4A permission for each activity, shown on the FCA register.
What is a regulated activity? Under FSMA s.22 it needs a specified activity (dealing, arranging, advising...) carried on in relation to a specified investment (shares, bonds, deposits, contracts of insurance...). The detail is in the Regulated Activities Order 2001. If the activity is not connected to a specified investment it is not regulated - and not every activity fits every investment (effecting a contract of insurance relates only to insurance). A firm doing several activities needs permission for each.
| Consequence | Detail |
|---|---|
| Criminal offence | Maximum 2 years' imprisonment and/or an unlimited fine (Crown Court) |
| Defence | Took all reasonable precautions and exercised due diligence |
| Contracts | Unenforceable by the unauthorised person against the other party (also where made through the activities of someone breaching the prohibition) |
| Other party's remedies | Recover money or property transferred, plus compensation for loss |
Worked through: Mrs X buys shares on the recommendation of UNA Ltd, later found to be unauthorised. She can keep the shares, or sue UNA for her money and damages (handing the shares back) - and UNA's staff face up to two years.
1.6 Company law I: schemes, restructuring plans, squeeze-out and sell-out
▼Schemes of arrangement (Part 26 CA 2006) syllabus 1.2.1
A scheme of arrangement is a statutory compromise between a company and its shareholders and/or creditors. The directors propose it, the affected classes approve it, the court sanctions it, and it takes immediate effect. It can be used to acquire a company or business, merge companies, acquire minority shares, create a new holding company, run an MBO/MBI, demerge, split a group, or declare a creditor moratorium.
Three stages:
- Explanatory statement sent with the notice of the members'/creditors' meetings - effect of the scheme, purpose, and any impact on directors' personal interests;
- Meetings of each class, with court permission: approval needs a majority in number and 75% in value of those present and voting (in person or by proxy);
- Court sanction: the court asks whether a member of the class, acting in their own interest, might reasonably approve. The order must be filed with the Registrar within seven days; the scheme then binds every holder in the class, including dissenters.
Most public-company takeovers now use schemes, although the 2015 change to stamp duty removed the tax advantage over contractual offers.
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Binding on all shareholders once approved | Court approval can take a long time |
| Immediate transfer of shares | Costly - counsel required, extensive documents; complex for holders to understand |
| In a takeover, not bound by the normal Takeover Code timetable but by the more flexible Appendix 7 timetable | Recommended bids only - not usable for a hostile bid |
| 75% vote gives certainty of 100% of the shares | Target and its directors control timing, so a bidder risks withdrawal (e.g. if a higher offer arrives); only 75% of those voting is needed, which may disadvantage small minorities |
Part 26A restructuring plans syllabus 1.2.1
Inserted by the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Act 2020 (from 26 June 2020), modelled on the scheme but stricter on who can use it and more flexible on dissent.
| Point | Part 26 scheme | Part 26A restructuring plan |
|---|---|---|
| Who can use it | Any company | Only companies in financial difficulty that may not continue as a going concern; purpose is to eliminate, reduce, prevent or mitigate those difficulties |
| Voting | Majority in number and 75% in value | By value only (debt or shares) |
| Dissenting class | Blocks the scheme | Court can still sanction if no dissenting class would be worse off than under the relevant alternative and at least 75% of a class that would receive a payment or have a genuine economic interest in that alternative voted in favour |
| Participation | Meetings of classes | Every creditor/member whose rights are affected must be able to participate, unless a class has no genuine economic interest |
Squeeze-out and sell-out (CA 2006 ss.974-985) syllabus 1.2.2
These sections deal with the minority left after a takeover offer. Learn them as a pair of opposite rights with different tests:
| Squeeze-out (s.979) | Sell-out (s.983) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who acts | The bidder compels minorities to sell | A non-accepting shareholder compels the bidder to buy |
| Threshold | Acquired/agreed to acquire 90% of the shares the offer relates to AND 90% of the voting rights attached to them | Acquired/contracted to acquire at least 90% in value of all shares in the target |
| Time limit | Notice within 3 months of the last date the offer can be accepted, or 6 months of the offer date, whichever is EARLIER | Exercise within 3 months from the later of the end of the acceptance period or the date of the notice telling holders of the right |
| Price | The price of the original offer | (Bidder buys on the offer terms) |
1.7 Company law II: pre-emption, capital, financial assistance, inspectors
▼Pre-emption rights (s.561 and following) syllabus 1.2.4
When a company issues new equity shares wholly for cash it must first offer them to existing shareholders pro rata, so they can protect their percentage holding. They do not apply where shares are issued for other shares or assets (share-for-share acquisition, vendor placing). Private companies can exclude them in their articles; public companies (and therefore listed ones) cannot.
| Issue | Pre-emptive? | Can holders sell the entitlement? | Surplus on unsold shares |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rights issue | Yes - offered to all holders in proportion | Yes (or take up part, or ignore) | Shares not taken up may be sold in the market and any surplus over the issue price is paid to the non-participating holders |
| Open offer | Yes | No | Surplus is not paid to non-participants |
| Secondary placing | No - offered to new incoming holders | n/a | n/a |
Any pre-emptive offer (s.562) must allow at least 14 days to accept.
Disapplying pre-emption rights (listed companies) syllabus 1.2.4
To issue shares non-pre-emptively a public company needs a special resolution (ss.569-573) - either at the AGM (a general disapplication up to limits) or at a general meeting for a specific issue (generally 14 days' notice). The Companies Act and Listing Rules cap the authority at five years.
| Limit | Number |
|---|---|
| Statutory maximum period of a disapplication | 5 years |
| Investor-committee guidance: general approval, one year | 5% of issued share capital |
| Investor-committee guidance: rolling basis | 7.5% over three years |
| Above these levels | Specific approval at a general meeting |
| Premium listed: non-pre-emptive issue discount cap | 10% to the middle market price; more needs a general meeting |
The 10% discount restriction does not apply to standard-listed companies or those on AIM or the Aquis Growth Market.
Reduction of share capital (s.641) syllabus 1.2.3
Share capital belongs to the company, not the shareholders, and cannot simply be paid out - the principle of capital maintenance, which protects creditors. The Act names three purposes for a reduction: to extinguish or reduce liability on shares not fully paid; to cancel capital not represented by assets; or to return capital in excess of requirements.
| Private company | Public company (plc) | |
|---|---|---|
| Resolution | Special resolution (articles must not prohibit) | Special resolution |
| Extra requirement | Directors' solvency statement; at least one shareholder must remain | Must be confirmed by the court; the reduction cannot take effect later than the date of the resolution |
Financial assistance (ss.678-680) syllabus 1.2.6
A public company or its subsidiary may not directly or indirectly give financial assistance for the purchase of its own shares, or to reduce/discharge a liability incurred for that purpose. It includes gifts, guarantees, security, indemnities, releases or waivers, and any assistance that materially reduces net assets - a classic example is a target pledging its assets as security for the bidder's acquisition finance. Consequences: a criminal offence, related contracts are void, the company and officers may face a fine and/or up to two years' imprisonment, and directors who initiate it breach their duties and are liable to the company for losses.
Exceptions: the principal purpose is not to give assistance; assistance is an incidental part of a larger purpose; lending in the ordinary course of business; loans to employees under an employee share scheme. Private companies are outside the rules unless they are subsidiaries of a public company.
Investigations by inspectors (ss.1035-1039) syllabus 1.2.5
Members may apply to the Department for Business and Trade (DBT) for an inspector; the DBT can also act on its own discretion in four situations: the company may have been run with intent to defraud creditors, prejudicially to members, or for unlawful/fraudulent purposes; promoters or managers may be guilty of fraud or misconduct; the company failed to give members proper information; or it was formed for a fraudulent or unlawful purpose. The DBT need not warn the company. Inspectors have broad powers to demand information, question people under oath, obtain a search warrant, and report to the Secretary of State, who can direct the scope of the inquiry, terminate it once criminal matters are passed to a prosecutor, and set the report's contents and time limit.
1.8 Company law III: meetings, shareholder rights, the plc and directors
▼Meeting notice periods syllabus 1.2.7-1.2.8
Public companies must hold an AGM within six months of the financial year end; private companies need not, unless their articles say so. Any shareholder entitled to attend and vote can appoint a proxy (who need not be a shareholder) to attend, speak and vote.
| Meeting | Notice | Short-notice consent |
|---|---|---|
| Public company AGM | 21 calendar days | Unanimous agreement of all shareholders |
| Private company AGM | 14 days | - |
| GM - listed company (regulated market such as LSE Main Market; not AIM/Aquis Growth) | 21 days; may be cut to 14 if members pass an annual AGM resolution allowing it and electronic voting is available (most do) | 95% of voting rights (public company) |
| GM - other companies | 14 days | 90% of shareholders (private company) |
All members and every director are entitled to notice (s.310); notice can be in hard copy, electronic form, on a website or a combination.
Calling a meeting and moving resolutions syllabus 1.2.7-1.2.8
- s.303 - shareholders with 5% of voting shares can require directors to call a GM (public and private). The request states the business and may include a draft resolution. Directors must convene within 21 days of receipt, for a meeting held no more than 28 days after the convening notice.
- s.305 - if directors fail, the requesting shareholders (or those holding more than 50% of the requesters' rights) may call it themselves and recover reasonable expenses.
- s.306 - the court can call a GM where it is impractical to do so normally, and may set a quorum of one.
- Members can force the company to circulate a resolution, or a statement of no more than 1,000 words, if they hold 5% of voting rights or are at least 100 shareholders averaging at least £100 paid up each. The requesters bear the cost unless notice is given before the end of the previous financial year.
Resolutions and quorum syllabus 1.2.7-1.2.8
One vote per share unless the articles say otherwise. A meeting can only pass resolutions if quorate - two members unless the articles specify otherwise.
| Type | Threshold | Examples from the workbook |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary | Simple majority (over 50% of votes cast) | Approving annual accounts; appointing/removing auditors or directors; approving a dividend; authorising a director conflict in advance |
| Special | 75% of votes cast | Changing the name; waiving pre-emption rights; de-listing a public company; share buy-backs; changing the articles; voluntary winding-up; reducing capital; re-registering a private company as public |
Being a plc, and public offers by private companies syllabus 1.2.10-1.2.11
The two company types are compared below.
| Public limited company (plc) | Private company | |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum members | 2 | 1 |
| Minimum capital | £50,000 issued, with all share premium and at least 25% of nominal value paid up | None stated |
| Name ending | "plc" or "public limited company" | "ltd" or "limited" (with exceptions such as unlimited or charitable companies) |
| Sell shares to the public? | Yes; may seek listing or admission to a market, but need not be listed | No (s.755 offence) - may only issue to people known to it |
If a private company does sell to the public, the allotment remains valid but the company and officers face fines; the exception is where it commits to re-register as public within six months of issue. Re-registration (s.90) needs a special resolution, the share-capital requirements, changed name and articles, and a balance sheet dated no more than seven months before the application, with an unqualified audit report and an auditor statement that net assets were not less than called-up share capital plus undistributable reserves - and no adverse change since.
Memorandum and Articles of Association syllabus 1.2.10
Two documents form the constitution. The memorandum is the "external" document. Since 2009 it only states the company name, whether it has share capital (limited by shares or guarantee), and that each subscriber wishes to form the company and become a member; the company is assumed to have unlimited capacity unless the articles restrict it. The articles are the internal rulebook between company and members - classes of share, general meeting mechanics (notice, short notice, quorum, chair), directors' requirements, and permitted/prohibited actions (pre-emption, transfer restrictions, borrowing). Model articles are in the Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008; the articles can only be altered by special resolution at a general meeting.
Directors' duties (ss.170-175) and conflicts of interest syllabus 1.2.12
The duties also bind shadow directors (people whose instructions the directors habitually follow) and sit alongside SM&CR and the governance codes. The main duties:
- act within the constitution and use powers only for their proper purpose;
- promote the success of the company for its members as a whole in good faith, having regard to long-term consequences, employees, business relationships, community and environment, reputation for high standards of conduct, and the need to act fairly between members;
- exercise independent judgement;
- exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence (objective standard, raised by the director's actual skill);
- avoid conflicts of interest (s.175);
- not accept benefits from third parties;
- declare an interest in a proposed transaction or arrangement, and not profit personally from the role (for example by diverting a company opportunity).
Conflicts (s.175) cover interests that are actual or potential, direct or indirect, conflicting actually or potentially - for example a directorship of a competitor. Declarations can be blanket or ad hoc; failing to declare an interest in an existing transaction is a criminal offence. Articles normally bar a conflicted director from voting.
| Situation | How it can be dealt with |
|---|---|
| Anticipated conflict | Authorised in advance by a majority of the other directors (only if the articles permit) or by an ordinary resolution of shareholders in a GM |
| Conflict already arisen (e.g. unforeseen events) | Can be ratified by shareholders only - not by the directors |
1.9 UK MiFID II: purpose, scope and exemptions
▼Why MiFID exists and how it works in the UK syllabus 1.3.1
MiFID was built around the passport (a firm authorised in one member state provides investment services across the others). It took effect in the UK in 2007; MiFID II and MiFIR took effect on 3 January 2018. Passporting no longer applies to the UK. A key aim is common investor protection - best possible result for the client, information disclosure, suitability and appropriateness, and inducement rules - resting on a general duty to act in the client's best interest, ahead of the firm's own. Its main impact on corporate finance is indirect, through retail fund management, research and securities trading.
Post-Brexit, HM Treasury made statutory instruments (e.g. the MiFID II EU Exit Regulations, SI 2018/1403) and the FCA amended its Handbook, technical standards and rulebooks to reflect powers moving from ESMA. In some cases UK MiFID II standards apply to a wider range of firms than the Directive requires, to keep consistency and existing UK standards.
UK MiFIR applies to UK-headquartered investment firms and credit institutions that (1) hold Part 4A permission for investment services/activities and (2) would have needed authorisation under MiFID II / CRD IV if headquartered in the EEA before exit day; also to UK market operators, UK trading venues, CCPs, benchmark owners, and third-country firms operating in the UK after an HM Treasury equivalence decision.
MiFID firms, non-MiFID firms and activity mapping syllabus 1.3.2-1.3.3
A MiFID firm regularly provides one or more MiFID services or activities to others professionally (with or without ancillary services) in relation to MiFID financial instruments. Non-MiFID ("out-of-scope") firms include insurance undertakings, employee schemes, individuals managing their own assets, and firms not providing investment services.
| MiFID activity | Broadly equivalent UK activity |
|---|---|
| Core: receipt and transmission of orders | Arranging deals in investments |
| Core: execution of orders for clients | Dealing as agent |
| Core: dealing on own account | Dealing as principal |
| Core: portfolio management | Managing investments |
| Core: investment advice | Advising on investments |
| Core: firm-commitment underwriting/placing | Dealing as principal; dealing as agent |
| Core: placing without firm commitment | Dealing as principal; arranging deals |
| Core: operating MTFs / OTFs | Operating an MTF / operating an OTF |
| Ancillary: safekeeping and administration | Safeguarding and administering investments |
| Ancillary: advice to undertakings on capital structure, strategy, mergers and purchases | Dealing (principal/agent); arranging deals; advising on investments; agreeing to carry on regulated activities |
| Ancillary: investment research and financial analysis | Advising on investments; agreeing to carry on regulated activities |
Instruments covered, not covered, and exemptions syllabus 1.3.3
Covered financial instruments: transferable securities; money market instruments; units in collective investment undertakings (UCITS); derivatives on securities, currencies, interest rates/yields or financial indices/measures (physically or cash settled); commodity derivatives traded on a regulated market and/or MTF, OTC commodity derivatives cash-settled at option, and certain physically settled OTC commodity derivatives not for commercial purposes; credit derivatives; financial CFDs; and derivatives on climatic variables, freight rates, emission allowances, inflation rates or other statistics.
Not covered: bank accounts and spot FX (including spot FX used to settle a short-dated securities settlement of two days or less, as the question bank frames it).
| Exemptions (MiFID Articles 2 and 3) | Examples |
|---|---|
| Article 2 - MiFID does not apply to | Insurance undertakings (including reinsurers); group treasury activities; professional investors investing only for themselves; collective investment undertakings and pension funds and their depositaries/managers; commodity producers and traders; employee-scheme administration; persons administering their own assets; undertakings not providing investment services; incidental business within a regulated profession (covers DPBs such as accountants and lawyers) |
| Article 3 - optional exemption for firms that | only give investment advice and receive/transmit orders; do not hold client funds or securities; and transmit orders only to other MiFID firms and certain other institutions |
1.10 Ch 1 cheat sheet
▼All the numbers and names
| Item | Answer |
|---|---|
| FSMA in force / FSA | 2001 / single regulator for prudential and conduct |
| FSA 2012 (in effect 2013) | Created FPC, FCA, PRA |
| FSA 2021 | IFPR Jan 2022; UK MAR criminal max 7 to 10 years |
| FSMA 2023 | Royal Assent June 2023; secondary objective (competitiveness/growth) for FCA and PRA; some provisions Aug 2023, rest 1 Jan 2024 |
| FCA objectives | 1 strategic (markets work well) + 3 operational (consumer, integrity, competition) |
| PRA objectives | 3: safety and soundness; insurance policyholders; secondary competition |
| Temporary product rules | Up to 12 months |
| Principles of Good Regulation | 8 |
| UK RIEs / ROIEs / DIEs | 5 / 32 (Dec 2024) / 29 |
| RCH supervisor | Bank of England (RIE supervisor is the FCA) |
| DPBs | 10 bodies, 5 professions |
| General prohibition | FSMA s.19 - max 2 years and/or unlimited fine; contracts unenforceable by the unauthorised person |
| Scheme approval | Majority in number + 75% in value; court order filed within 7 days |
| Squeeze-out (s.979) | 90% of offer shares + 90% voting rights; notice within 3 months of close / 6 months of offer, earlier |
| Sell-out (s.983) | 90% in value of all shares; 3 months from later date |
| Pre-emption offer period | At least 14 days |
| Disapplication | Special resolution; max 5 years; 5% per year / 7.5% rolling 3 yrs; 10% discount (premium listed) |
| Capital reduction (plc) | Special resolution + court confirmation (private: solvency statement) |
| Financial assistance | Public co. and subsidiaries; criminal; contracts void; up to 2 years |
| AGM notice | Public 21 days; private 14 days; public AGM within 6 months of year end |
| GM notice | Listed 21 days (14 with AGM authority); others 14; short notice 95% public / 90% private |
| Requisition of a GM (s.303) | 5%; directors call within 21 days, meeting within 28 days of notice |
| Resolutions | Ordinary: over 50%; special: 75% |
| Quorum | Two members unless articles differ |
| plc minimums | 2 members; £50,000; all premium + 25% of nominal paid up |
| s.793 look-back | Three years |
| MiFID II / MiFIR | Effective 3 January 2018; UK MiFIR from 1 January 2021 (onshored) |
| Not covered by MiFID | Bank accounts; spot FX |