Chapter 3 · Corporate Governance

5 of 50 exam questions (~10%) · UK Corporate Governance Code 2024 · QCA · Wates · UK Stewardship Code · ESG, Section 172 and the ESG sourcebook
← Back to quiz
Why this chapter matters. 5 of 50 exam questions (~10%) - the lightest chapter, but the facts are countable and quick to learn. Trap zones: Code numbers (5 sections, 18 principles, 41 provisions; nine-year chair; 50% NEDs, 25% for funds); the Code is not law and not part of the Listing Rules - comply or explain via UKLR 6.6.6(3); QCA (10 principles) vs Wates (6) vs Stewardship (investors); s.414CB applies to PIEs but s.414CZA (s.172(1) statement) to large companies; and the £5bn / 30 June ESG 2 rules.

3.1 The UK Corporate Governance Code 2024: status and comply-or-explain

▼

What governance is, and where the Code comes from syllabus 3.1.1

The Code opens with a definition: corporate governance is the system by which companies are directed and controlled. Boards are responsible for governance; the shareholders' role is to appoint the directors and the auditors and be satisfied that an appropriate governance structure exists. The board sets strategic aims, provides leadership, supervises management and reports to shareholders on its stewardship, all subject to law, regulation and shareholders in general meeting.

The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) publishes the Code to support effective, entrepreneurial management and confidence in reporting and governance. Its lineage: the Cadbury, Greenbury and Hampel reports of the 1990s (accountability and directors' pay), the Higgs report on non-executive directors and the Smith report on audit committees - together the Combined Code. After the 2007-08 crisis the Walker Review looked at bank governance; the FRC's parallel review (reported late 2009) produced the renamed UK Corporate Governance Code, stressing the spirit as well as the letter of the Code and better board-shareholder engagement - the FRC then created the Stewardship Code for investors. The current edition is the 2024 Code, in effect from 1 January 2025.

Memory hook: Cadbury (1992 start), Greenbury (pay), Hampel (combine), Higgs (NEDs), Smith (audit committees) - then Walker after the crisis.

Legal status, scope and the disclosure statement syllabus 3.1.2

The Code is not a rigid set of rules and there is no legal obligation to comply; it is a guide to good board practice. It has five sections, 18 principles and 41 provisions. It is not part of the Listing Rules, but UKLR 6.6.6(3) requires UK-listed companies to include a corporate governance report (disclosure statement) in the annual report and accounts that:

  • describes how the company has applied (complied with) the main principles;
  • states whether it has complied with all the provisions;
  • identifies any provisions it has not complied with, the period of non-compliance for ongoing provisions, and the reasons.

Who is covered: all companies with a listing of equity shares in the UK, whether incorporated in the UK or overseas. Smaller listed companies may find some provisions disproportionate, and certain provisions do not apply below the FTSE 350. For standard-listed companies and those on AIM or the Aquis Growth Market the Code is voluntary (though encouraged). Externally managed investment companies often have different board structures; the AIC Code and Guide can help them.

Trap: the Code is not part of the Listing Rules and is not law - the disclosure obligation comes from UKLR 6.6.6(3).

"Comply or explain" syllabus 3.1.2

Provisions are followed on a comply or explain basis. A company may judge that an alternative approach achieves better governance for it - but it must explain its justification and reasoning in the annual report. The explanation should be clear and detailed, show how actual practice aligns with the principle behind the provision and contributes to good governance, and is judged by shareholders on its merits. Departure is tolerable only if explained; shareholders may use the explanation when deciding their votes. Both boards and investors value the flexibility.

Quick check
A listed company decides not to follow one provision of the UK Corporate Governance Code. Under "comply or explain" it must:

3.2 The five sections and 18 principles

▼

Overview: five sections syllabus 3.1.1

The Code has five sections (the same letters run through the principles - e.g. Principle A, J, L are cited in the workbook):

#SectionFocus
1Board Leadership and Company PurposeLeadership, strategy and policy from the board
2Division of ResponsibilitiesWho does what on the board; independence of chair and NEDs
3Composition, Succession and EvaluationAppointments, refreshment, diversity, evaluation
4Audit, Risk and Internal ControlAudit independence, fair/balanced reporting, risk management
5RemunerationPay policy aligned with strategy; no director sets their own pay
Memory hook: Leadership - Division - Composition - Audit - Remuneration (L, D, C, A, R).

Section 1 - Board Leadership and Company Purpose syllabus 3.1.1

Main principles:

  • Principle A: a successful company has an effective, entrepreneurial board whose job is the company's long-term sustainable success - creating value for shareholders while contributing to wider society.
  • The board sets the company's purpose, values and strategy, satisfies itself that these and the culture are aligned; directors act with integrity and lead by example.
  • The board ensures the resources are in place to meet objectives and measure performance, and establishes a framework of prudent and effective controls enabling risk to be assessed and managed.
  • The board ensures effective engagement with, and participation from, shareholders and stakeholders.
  • Workforce policies and practices are consistent with company values; the workforce can raise concerns.

Provisions focus on the business model and risks, culture, regular shareholder engagement, dealing with shareholder opposition and recording concerns in board minutes.

Section 2 - Division of Responsibilities syllabus 3.1.1

  • The chair leads the board and is responsible for its overall effectiveness in directing the company: demonstrates objective judgement, promotes openness and debate, builds constructive board relations, ensures NEDs contribute effectively and directors get accurate, timely, clear information.
  • The board has a suitable mix of executive and non-executive (especially independent non-executive) directors so no individual or small group dominates; a clear division between board leadership and executive leadership of the business.
  • NEDs have sufficient time; they provide constructive challenge, strategic guidance, specialist advice and hold management to account.
  • The board, supported by the company secretary, has the policies, processes, information, time and resources to function well.

Independence is judged against current or recent connections to the company or its executives - employment, shareholdings, commercial arrangements, family relations. Provisions focus on independence of the chair and NEDs; NEDs have the primary role in appointing and removing executives; board and committee responsibilities are written down; all directors have access to the company secretary. The 50% minimum non-executive membership does not apply to all boards - for UK funds the NED requirement is 25%.

Quick check
The Code's general minimum non-executive director membership is 50%. For UK funds, the board NED membership requirement is:
Trap: chair leads the board; the CEO leads the business - the Code wants a clear division so no one dominates.

Section 3 - Composition, Succession and Evaluation syllabus 3.1.1

Main principles:

  • Board appointments follow a formal, rigorous and transparent procedure; an effective succession plan for board and senior management; both based on merit and objective criteria, promoting diversity, inclusion and equal opportunity (Principle J).
  • The board and committees have the right combination of skills, experience and knowledge; length of service considered and membership regularly refreshed.
  • Annual evaluation of the board (composition, diversity, how well members work together - Principle L) and of individual directors' continued effective contribution.

Provisions: effective nomination and remuneration committees; all directors subject to annual re-election; the chair's tenure should not extend beyond nine years; open advertising and external search encouraged for chair and NED appointments; rigorous assessment of the board, committees, chair and directors, with full disclosure of the nomination committee's work.

Memory hook: "annual re-election, nine-year chair". Diversity appears in principles J (appointments) and L (evaluation).

Section 4 - Audit, Risk and Internal Control syllabus 3.1.1

Main principles: the board sets formal and transparent policies to ensure the independence and effectiveness of internal and external audit and to be satisfied on the integrity of financial and narrative statements; it presents a fair, balanced and understandable assessment of the company's position and prospects; it establishes procedures to manage risk, oversee the internal control framework and decide which principal risks, and how much of them, the company will accept in pursuing its long-term strategy.

Provisions focus on the audit committee: advising whether the annual report is fair, balanced and understandable and disclosing significant issues; the directors' responsibility statement; a robust assessment of emerging and principal risks; monitoring risk management and internal control systems; and the going concern and viability statement.

Section 5 - Remuneration syllabus 3.1.1

  • Remuneration policies support strategy and promote long-term sustainable success; executive pay is aligned with purpose and values and clearly linked to delivery of long-term strategy.
  • A formal and transparent procedure sets executive pay policy and director/senior management pay; no director is involved in deciding their own remuneration outcome.
  • Directors use independent judgement and discretion when authorising outcomes, taking account of company and individual performance and wider circumstances.
Quick check
Under the Code's remuneration principles, which of the following is correct?

What changed in the 2024 edition syllabus 3.1.1

Changes in effect from 1 January 2025:

  • a revised framework of prudent and effective controls - stronger basis for reporting on, and evidencing, their effectiveness;
  • improving how comply or explain works, drawing on FRC research and reports;
  • revisions reflecting board and audit committee responsibility for sustainability and ESG reporting and related assurance under the company's audit and assurance policy;
  • alignment with legal and regulatory changes from the Government's White Paper response, including stronger reporting on malus and clawback.

Separately, the FRC is set to become the Audit, Reporting and Governance Authority (ARGA); primary legislation is needed to create it and give it powers.

Trap: the 2024 Code is in effect from 1 January 2025 - "2024" is the edition, not the start date.

3.3 Other codes: QCA, Wates and the UK Stewardship Code

▼

The QCA Corporate Governance Code (AIM and Aquis Growth) syllabus 3.2.1

Companies quoted on AIM must follow a recognised governance code on a comply or explain basis. No code is compulsory for standard-listed or Aquis Growth Market companies, but many adopt the Quoted Companies Alliance (QCA) Code as a simpler alternative (for certain larger Aquis Growth companies adopting a code is being made compulsory). The workbook cites 89% of AIM companies following the QCA Code (as at 22 August 2023). It is similar in approach to the UK Code but less prescriptive, built on ten principles:

#Principle (summarised)
1Strategy and business model promoting long-term shareholder value
2Understand and meet shareholder needs and expectations
3Wider stakeholder and social responsibilities
4Embed effective risk management (opportunities and threats)
5Well-functioning, balanced board led by the chair
6Directors have up-to-date experience, skills and capabilities
7Evaluate board performance against clear objectives
8Corporate culture based on ethical values and behaviours
9Governance structures fit for purpose
10Communicate governance and performance through dialogue with shareholders and stakeholders
Trap: UK Code = 5 sections, 18 principles, 41 provisions. QCA = 10 principles. Wates = 6 principles.

The Wates Principles (large private companies) syllabus 3.3.1

A framework to help large private companies raise governance standards and report against a code. Under the Companies (Miscellaneous Reporting) Regulations 2018, a private company must disclose its governance arrangements in the directors' report and on its website - including whether it follows a formal code - if it has more than 2,000 employees, and/or turnover over £200 million and a balance sheet over £2 billion (as the workbook words it). Six principles:

#PrincipleCovers
1Purpose and LeadershipPurpose, values and culture, strategy
2Board CompositionBalance and diversity, size and structure, effectiveness
3Director ResponsibilitiesAccountability, integrity of information
4Opportunity and RiskOpportunity, risk, responsibilities
5RemunerationSetting remuneration, policies, delegating decisions, subsidiaries
6Stakeholder Relationships and EngagementExternal impacts, stakeholders, workforce

Stakeholder engagement runs throughout: firms must outline how they engage the workforce and other stakeholders and show the issues were raised and considered by the board.

Quick check
The Wates Corporate Governance Principles are aimed primarily at:

The UK Stewardship Code 2020 syllabus 3.4.1

Aimed at institutional investors and running alongside the Corporate Governance Code, it defines stewardship as the responsible allocation, management and oversight of capital so as to create long-term value for clients and beneficiaries, with lasting benefits for the economy, environment and society. The Code and reporting against it are voluntary, set a standard above the regulatory minimum, and annex regulatory requirements that signatories' reports can help meet. It covers asset owners, asset managers and service providers (proxy advisers, investment consultants, data and research providers).

Links to regulation: under COBS 2.2.3 every UK-authorised asset manager must produce a statement of commitment to the Stewardship Code or explain why it is not appropriate to its business model. The UK implementation of the Shareholder Rights Directive II (SRD II) overlaps; the FCA said SRD II disclosures may sit in the same document as Stewardship Code reporting, but (PS19/13) firms must check the Stewardship disclosures are enough to meet FCA rules. The Code's purpose is better dialogue between shareholders and boards and more transparency on how investors oversee investee companies.

GroupPrinciples for asset owners and asset managers
Purpose and GovernancePurpose, strategy and culture; governance, resources and incentives; conflicts of interest; promoting well-functioning markets; review and assurance
Investment ApproachClient and beneficiary needs; stewardship, investment and ESG integration; monitoring managers and service providers
EngagementEngagement; collaboration; escalation
Exercising Rights and ResponsibilitiesActively exercise rights and responsibilities

Service providers have six principles: purpose, strategy and culture; governance, resources and incentives; conflicts of interest; promoting well-functioning markets; supporting clients' stewardship; review and assurance.

Trap: the Stewardship Code is for investors (asset owners/managers) and service providers - not for company boards. It is voluntary, but COBS 2.2.3 makes UK asset managers state commitment or explain.

3.4 ESG: Code, Stewardship, Section 172 and the ESG sourcebook

▼

The strategic report and non-financial reporting (CA 2006 ss.414A-414D) syllabus 3.5.1

UK companies (other than those reporting under the small companies regime) must report on non-financial matters in the strategic and directors' reports. The key sections:

SectionWhat it doesApplies to
s.414COverall framework and main principles for strategic report contentCompanies required to prepare a strategic report
s.414CBNon-financial information (NFI) statementPublic interest entities (PIEs)
s.414CZASection 172(1) statementLarge companies

A PIE is a traded company, a banking company, an authorised insurance company or a company carrying on insurance market activity. Requirements vary by category (PIEs, quoted companies under and over 500 employees, large and medium-sized private companies and qualifying partnerships).

Non-PIEs: to the extent needed to understand the business, the strategic report covers environmental matters, employees, and social, community and human rights issues, with related policies and their effectiveness; a quoted company that omits any kind must say which.

PIE NFI statement (s.414CB) must cover at least: environmental matters, the company's employees, social matters, respect for human rights, and anti-corruption and anti-bribery matters - including a brief business model description, policies and due diligence, the outcome of the policies, principal risks (and how managed, with adverse-impact relationships where relevant and proportionate), and relevant non-financial KPIs.

Quick check
Under Section 414CB of the Companies Act 2006, the non-financial information (NFI) statement requirement applies to:

The Section 172(1) statement syllabus 3.5.1

s.172 - the duty to promote the success of the company for the benefit of members as a whole, having regard to: (a) likely long-term consequences of decisions; (b) employees' interests; (c) fostering relationships with suppliers, customers and others; (d) impact on the community and environment; (e) reputation for high standards of business conduct; (f) the need to act fairly between members. A s.172(1) statement in the strategic report (s.414CZA) describes how the directors have had regard to (a)-(f). There is no single template; FRC guidance suggests covering:

  • the issues, factors and stakeholders directors consider relevant and how they formed their view;
  • the main methods used to engage with stakeholders and understand the issues;
  • the effect of that regard on the company's decisions and strategies in the year.

Large private companies: those with over 250 employees must also give an employee engagement statement (action to inform and consult employees, encourage involvement, promote awareness of financial and economic factors; how directors engaged with employees and had regard to their interests, and the effect on principal decisions) and a statement on the policy for employing disabled persons. Those with over 500 employees must provide KPI analysis (including environmental and employee matters) under s.414C(4)(b), matters of strategic importance required by regulations under s.416(4) (s.414C(11)), and a s.172(1) statement. The s.172 report of a private (unquoted) company must be published on its website.

Trap: s.172 list has SIX factors (a)-(f); the statement is in the strategic report (s.414CZA) - do not mix up with s.414CB (NFI, PIEs).

The FCA ESG sourcebook (ESG 1.1, 1.2, 2) syllabus 3.5.1

The ESG sourcebook sits in the Business Standards block of the Handbook and reflects the 2021 climate-related disclosure instrument for asset managers and owners (FCA 2021/62). ESG 1.1 - purpose - four outcomes:

  • better outcomes for clients and consumers through greater transparency on how firms manage climate-related risks and opportunities in investment decisions;
  • deeper consideration of climate-related risks and opportunities by in-scope firms;
  • the anti-greenwashing rules and guidance for sustainability claims about products or services;
  • requirements when firms use sustainability labelling.

ESG 2 requires disclosure of climate-related financial information consistent with the TCFD recommendations, on managed or administered assets. Firms publish a TCFD entity report annually by 30 June. A firm is exempt while its in-scope assets under management or administration are less than £5 billion, measured as a three-year rolling average on an annual assessment. ESG 1.1.5 acknowledges data and methodology challenges in a transition period but still expects firms to disclose metrics and scenario analysis where fair, clear and not misleading, and to explain limitations and what is being done.

ESG 1.2 - application:

Type of firmTCFD in-scope business
Asset managers - any firmPortfolio management
UK UCITS management company; ICVC that is a UCITS without a separate managerManaging a UK UCITS
Full-scope UK AIFM; small authorised UK AIFMManaging an AIF
Asset owners - insurer or pure reinsurerProviding insurance-based investment products
Personal pension (excluding SIPP) or stakeholder pension operatorsOperating those schemes
SIPP operatorsOnly SIPPs containing the firm's insurance-based products (insurers) or specified items - a unit, an interest in a closed-ended fund, or a pre-set portfolio (other asset owners)
Worked example - the TCFD assets exemption
A firm's TCFD in-scope assets were £4.5bn, £5.0bn and £5.5bn over the last three annual assessments. Is it exempt from the ESG 2 disclosure requirements?
  1. 1 The test is a three-year rolling average of in-scope assets.
  2. 2 (4.5 + 5.0 + 5.5) / 3 = £5.0bn (illustrative figures).
  3. 3 The exemption applies only if the average is less than £5bn. It equals £5bn, so it is not exempt and must publish the TCFD entity report by 30 June.
Quick check
A firm is exempt from the ESG 2 (TCFD-aligned) disclosure requirements if its in-scope assets, on a three-year rolling average, are less than:
Memory hook: TCFD report = annual, by 30 June; exemption = under £5bn (3-year rolling average).

3.5 Ch 3 cheat sheet

▼

All the numbers and names

ItemAnswer
UK Corporate Governance CodePublished by the FRC; 2024 edition in effect from 1 January 2025
Structure5 sections; 18 principles; 41 provisions
StatusNot law, not part of the Listing Rules; UKLR 6.6.6(3) requires a governance report
Applies toCompanies with a listing of equity shares in the UK (UK or overseas); voluntary for standard-listed, AIM, Aquis Growth
ApproachComply or explain - explain in the annual report
5 sectionsBoard leadership and purpose; Division of responsibilities; Composition, succession, evaluation; Audit, risk, internal control; Remuneration
NED membershipGeneral minimum 50%; UK funds 25%
Chair tenureNot beyond nine years; all directors annually re-elected
RemunerationNo director decides their own pay
QCA Code10 principles; AIM comply or explain; 89% of AIM companies (22 Aug 2023)
Wates6 principles; large private companies (over 2,000 employees and/or over £200m turnover + £2bn balance sheet)
UK Stewardship Code 2020Voluntary; investors + service providers; COBS 2.2.3 statement of commitment or explain
Stewardship ESG principlesOwners/managers: 1 and 7; service providers: 5
s.414C / 414CB / 414CZAFramework / NFI statement (PIEs) / s.172(1) statement (large companies)
s.172 factorsSix: (a) long term, (b) employees, (c) relationships, (d) community/environment, (e) reputation, (f) fairness between members
Private co. employee statementsOver 250 employees: engagement + disabled persons; over 500: KPIs, s.414C(11), s.172 statement
ESG sourcebook4 outcomes; TCFD entity report annually by 30 June; exempt under £5bn (3-year rolling average)
FRC futureTo become ARGA (needs primary legislation)