2.1 Trade cycle, matching, clearing and CCPs
▼The four stages of the trade cycle syllabus 2.1
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| Trading (execution) | Counterparties agree to a transaction on specified terms |
| Pre-settlement and clearing | Trade instructions are matched; checks that the seller has the securities and the buyer has the cash |
| Settlement | Legal title moves from seller to buyer in exchange for cash, ideally simultaneously |
| Post-settlement | Management of failed trades and the accounting for trades |
Matching settlement instructions LO 2.1.1
Matching happens at two levels: (1) the trading counterparties compare trade details, either bilaterally, through the CSD's matching facility, or through a third-party central matching service (electronic order books auto-match); and (2) the custodians for each side compare settlement instructions before settlement date.
The data normally compared:
- Title of security and security identification code
- Counterparty details and account numbers (custodian depot or nostro account, BIC)
- Trade date, settlement date, trade price, quantity
- Purchase or sale; settlement currency; net settlement value
- Trading conditions (eg ex-dividend, ex-rights)
- For fixed income: number of days and amount of accrued interest
- Settlement method (DvP or FOP)
Clearing: bilateral vs CCP LO 2.1.2
Clearing is the process of defining and legally formalising each party's obligations: recording trade information, formalising the legal obligation, matching and confirming, agreeing the settlement procedure, calculating settlement obligations and sending instructions to brokers, custodians and the CSD, and managing margin (collateral paid to guarantee positions until settlement).
Trades can be cleared bilaterally, in which case each party carries direct credit risk against every counterparty, or through a central counterparty (CCP). Workbook examples: LCH (UK and Euronext markets, and much euro and sterling bond and repo business), Cboe Clear Europe (formerly EuroCCP, set up after MiFID mainly for MTF business), NSCC in the US (a DTCC subsidiary, for broker-to-broker equities, corporate and municipal bonds, UITs and ETFs), and Eurex Clearing (euro equities listed on Xetra).
How a CCP works LO 2.1.2
A CCP steps between the two sides, becoming buyer to every seller and seller to every buyer. This is novation, and it makes the original parties anonymous to each other. Benefits:
- Many bilateral credit exposures are replaced by one exposure to the CCP, and risk management (collateral and margin requests) is done with a single party.
- The CCP's default risk is typically much lower than an individual counterparty's, and regulators expect it to withstand severe shocks.
- The CCP must finalise settlement even if a participant fails. Its settlement guarantee scheme first uses the defaulter's property (eg its clearing fund deposit), then, if that is not enough, a mutual guarantee by the other participants.
- Regulators like CCPs: risk is spread and easier to monitor, and CCP controls act as an early warning system. EMIR sets common standards for CCPs operating in the EU.
| Member type | What it can do |
|---|---|
| Individual clearing member (ICM) | Clears only its own trades |
| General clearing member (GCM) | Clears its own trades and trades for other firms |
| Non-clearing member (NCM) | Trades in its own name but uses a GCM to clear, avoiding the capital and technology costs of clearing directly |
Drawbacks: substantial development cost partly borne by members; CCP fees and collateral costs; and lower settlement volumes reduce income for settlement agents unless they raise fees. A CCP does not remove default risk, it spreads and monitors it.
2.2 Netting and pre-settlement automation
▼Netting in pre-settlement LO 2.1.2
Netting is offsetting positions or obligations so that many are reduced to fewer (or one), and settlement occurs on the net figure. It lowers transaction and communication costs and cuts credit and liquidity risk. Instead of settling each trade gross with each counterparty, a CCP nets each participant's sales and purchases to a single securities transfer and a single cash transfer. A CSD may also offer settlement netting.
Liquidity illustration from the workbook: if US$1 million and US$900,000 of a company's shares are to be exchanged, trade-by-trade needs both parties to hold the gross amounts, whereas only US$100,000 of stock actually needs to move. Netting is especially valuable for illiquid stock that is hard or costly to obtain.
Third-party providers and messaging LO 2.1.3
| Provider | What to remember |
|---|---|
| DTCC ITP / CTM | ITP grew out of the Omgeo business and gives buy-side, sell-side and custodians end-to-end STP. Central Trade Manager (CTM) is DTCC's strategic platform for central matching of cross-border and domestic trades, automating trade confirmation across asset classes |
| MarketAxess Post-Trade | Matching system developed by ICMA, launched 1989 as one-stop matching and regulatory reporting for OTC bonds, equities, derivatives and repos. Formerly TRAX, acquired by MarketAxess in 2013 |
| OSTTRA | Post-trade services company for global OTC markets launched 1 September 2021, 50/50 owned by CME Group and IHS Markit, HQ London. Incorporates Traiana, TriOptima, Reset and MarkitSERV |
| FIX and SWIFT | FIX standardises pre-trade and execution messages; SWIFT offers standard electronic trade confirmation messages (see Ch 1) |
Automation removes back-and-forth manual communication and re-keying, ideally so that trade data is entered once and used through to settlement (STP).
Transaction reporting LO 2.1.4
Introduced under MiFID I in November 2007 and revised under MiFID II/MiFIR from 3 January 2018. Investment firms must report details of transactions in instruments traded on regulated markets, MTFs and OTFs, including instruments whose underlying is admitted to those venues (futures, options, CFDs). Reports go via an approved reporting mechanism (ARM) to the regulator on a T+1 basis (the business day after execution).
Purpose: to help regulators detect and investigate suspected market abuse (insider trading and market manipulation). Using an ARM does not transfer responsibility: the firm remains responsible for completeness, accuracy and timeliness, and penalties can be severe.
2.3 Settlement periods and the life-cycle
▼Settlement periods by market LO 2.2.1
| Market | Equities | Bonds / debt |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | T+2 (CHESS) | T+2 (Austraclear) |
| Brazil | T+2 (CBLC) | Corporate T+0 (CETIP); government T+0 (SELIC) |
| France | T+2 (Euroclear ESES) | T+2 (Euroclear ESES) |
| Germany | T+2 (Clearstream Banking Frankfurt) | T+2 (CBF) |
| Hong Kong | T+2 (HKSCC) | T+0 (CMU) |
| India | T+1 (CDSL or NSDL) | T+1 (CDSL/NSDL; government debt via Reserve Bank of India) |
| South Korea | T+2 (KSD) | T+0 (KSD) |
| Japan | T+2 (JASDEC) | Government debt T+1 (Bank of Japan) |
| UK | T+2 (CREST) | Corporate debt T+2 (CREST); gilts T+1 (CREST) |
| US | T+1 (DTC) | Corporate debt T+1 (DTC); government debt T+1 (Federal Reserve) |
The workbook adds that rolling settlement is the norm and that in May 2024 the US, Canada and Mexico moved to T+1. Under CSDR Article 5, EU regulated-market trades settle at a maximum of T+2.
The settlement life-cycle, step by step LO 2.2.3
For a cross-border trade the chain runs as follows. Note which participant sends each instruction:
| Step | Who | What |
|---|---|---|
| Order | Investment manager to broker | Places the order |
| Execution | Broker | Executes on an exchange, MTF, systematic internaliser or OTC (a global market maker may use a local one); notifies the manager by ETC or manually |
| Confirmation / affirmation | Manager and broker | For a block trade the manager gives the allocation across accounts, the broker issues a confirmation, the manager checks it and sends an affirmation |
| Settlement instruction | Manager to global custodian to subcustodian | The global custodian instructs its subcustodian (or settles itself if it is its own settlement agent) to settle at the local CSD |
| Positioning | Settlement agent to CSD | The CSD matches instructions and reports matches and mismatches; cash and securities must be in position on settlement date |
| Notification | CSD back down the chain | Settlement notice passes from subcustodian to global custodian to manager |
| Fails | All | Failed trades are investigated and repaired |
The requirement to give instructions ensures CSD/ICSD members control delivery from their accounts and cash payments; nothing moves without an instruction sent by an approved channel. On the broker side the broker instructs its own settlement agent, which instructs the CSD or ICSD. Formats vary across markets, brokers and instrument types, and non-standard formats cause mismatches.
Many managers outsource administration to a global custodian. Many hedge funds use an investment bank as prime broker for execution, clearing, settlement, credit lines, securities lending, collateral and cash management and reporting. A third-party clearing agent lets an investor avoid joining the clearing house itself; in Europe it is typically a clearing member of the main clearing houses and gives a single point of entry.
2.4 Depositary receipts
▼What a DR is and how it is created LO 2.2.2
A depositary receipt (DR) mirrors the shares of a foreign company but trades in the local market and currency. Creation steps (company listed in Country A, DR in Country B): a broker from B buys the shares in market A; they are deposited with a depository bank in market A; the depository bank creates DRs in market B and sets the ratio of DRs per underlying share. The DR then trades freely in B under B's regulation and tax rules, priced in currency B to mirror the underlying. Holders can normally convert back into shares; if a programme is terminated, holders are notified in advance and may exchange for shares.
| Type | Key points |
|---|---|
| ADR | Issued in the US in US dollars; must comply with SEC rules including full registration and Exchange Act reporting. Depository banks with the largest US share: BNY Mellon, Citi, J.P. Morgan |
| GDR | Lets issuers raise capital in two or more markets at once, broadening the shareholder base; can settle outside the market of issue (many at Euroclear Bank or Clearstream); listing requirements often lighter than for an ordinary share. Example: Acer (Taiwan), quoted in euros and dollars |
| Depositary interest (DI) | A DR issued against foreign securities so they can be settled and held at the local CSD. Non-UK companies traded in London normally settle as DIs in CREST. DI transfers are exempt from SDRT for foreign securities |
ADR vs holding foreign shares directly LO 2.2.2
| Issue | Foreign shares | ADR |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership restrictions | Some countries bar foreign ownership | As a US security, not subject to local restrictions |
| Settlement | May be an extended cycle and inefficient procedures | T+1 like any US-listed share |
| FX | Pay in foreign currency, so FX needed | Settles in US dollars |
| Dividends | Foreign currency, so periodic FX | Paid in US dollars (net of any proportional withholding by the depository bank) |
| Rights and corporate actions | Right to vote and to take part in rights issues | Typically a right to vote but not to participate in rights issues; holders get the sale proceeds of the rights. Varies with the depositary agreement |
| Liquidity | May be poor locally | Trades on US exchanges and OTC, so can be more liquid |
| Transfer taxes | UK share purchases generally 0.5% (1% Ireland) | 1.5% usually applies when chargeable UK or Irish securities go to a DR issuer or its nominee in return for a DR |
| Legal framework | May give limited protection | US securities legislation and accounting principles |
Fees: the sponsoring bank earns commission or fees, the depository earns fees, and holders typically pay a conversion fee to convert into (or out of) the underlying shares.
Pre-release: a depository may issue DRs before the shares are deposited. The shares must be delivered within a set period, usually three months, and only if the issuer confirms in writing it owns the shares, the pre-release is fully collateralised (cash or other acceptable collateral), the depository can close it out within a notice period, and required indemnities are given. Close-out is by presenting either the shares or the pre-released DRs.
2.5 Payment systems
▼CHIPS, Fedwire, CHAPS, Faster Payments, TARGET2, CLS LO 2.2.4
| System | Currency / region | Key features |
|---|---|---|
| CHIPS | US dollar (private sector) | Launched 1970 by the New York Clearing House Association. Multilateral netting with intra-day finality; small payments settle RTGS, others are netted. Participants pre-fund their account (level set by recent volume and size). End-of-day positive balances are credited via Fedwire. Messages via SWIFT |
| Fedwire | US dollar (Federal Reserve) | RTGS; transfers are immediate, final and irrevocable; completed the day they start, guaranteed final when the receiver is notified. Funds Service day opens 21:00 ET the previous calendar day and ends 19:00 ET; third-party transfer deadline 18:45 ET. Securities Service runs 8:30 to 15:30 ET (repositioning versus payment to 16:30, free of payment to 19:00 ET) |
| CHAPS | Sterling | UK high-value RTGS, irrevocable and risk-free; over 35 direct participants; usually open 06:00 to 18:00 Monday to Friday |
| Faster Payments | UK retail | Launched May 2008 for internet, telephone and standing-order payments; alongside BACS (direct debits and credits) and CHAPS; now part of Pay.UK (2018) |
| TARGET / TARGET2 | Euro | TARGET live January 1999 (decentralised); TARGET2 live November 2007, a single technical platform built by Banca d'Italia, Banque de France and Deutsche Bundesbank, who run it for the Eurosystem. Open 07:00 to 18:00 CET, customer-payment deadline 17:00 |
| CLS Bank | FX, multi-currency | Private initiative from 1996 backed by the largest FX banks; launched commercially 2002; eliminates Herstatt risk through payment versus payment (PvP). Now 18 central banks' currencies are eligible. Owned by 70+ large financial groups |
CLS membership: a settlement member must be a CLS shareholder, show financial and operational capability and liquidity, holds a multi-currency account with CLS Bank and can instruct directly for itself and customers. A user member has no CLS account: it is sponsored, and each of its instructions must be authorised by a designated settlement member and settles through that member's account.
CLS's original seven currencies were AUD, CAD, USD, EUR, JPY, CHF and GBP; further currencies were added in September 2003 (four), late 2004 (four), May 2008 (two) and November 2015 (one).
2.6 FOP, DvP and finality
▼Free of payment vs delivery versus payment LO 2.2.5
A trade is only settled when both the securities transfer and the cash transfer are final and irrevocable. Regulators and central banks recommend minimising the credit risk created when one leg is delivered without receiving the other.
| FOP (free of payment) | DvP (delivery versus payment) | |
|---|---|---|
| Exchange | Separate, non-simultaneous cash and securities | Securities transfer is final if, and only if, the funds transfer is final (simultaneous exchange) |
| Risk | One or both parties deliver before receiving: higher risk | Both parties protected against counterparty default |
| Regulatory view | Discouraged | Encouraged wherever possible |
Four ways to achieve DvP: (1) an RTGS system (continuous, order-by-order settlement of funds and securities); (2) netting systems giving finality by end of day, provided intra-day transfers are final and end-of-day net payments are assured even if participants default; (3) on the books of a CSD with combined clearing and depository, linked to a final payments system (central bank money); (4) delivery against a guaranteed cheque giving cleared funds.
CREST: Euroclear UK & International provides DvP in central bank money with simultaneous, irrevocable transfer of cash and securities (DvP model 1) for sterling and euro. Full legal title transfers at settlement for UK-registered shares and government bonds. At settlement the buyer's settlement bank pays the seller's settlement bank across the books of the central bank (Bank of England for sterling), which greatly reduces the risk of a counterparty's settlement bank failing.
Finality, gross vs net trade-offs LO 2.2.5
Every settlement system must fix the moment of finality of transfer in its rules through binding contracts, so that after finality the buyer can use the securities and the seller the cash with no risk of unwinding.
| Gross / trade-for-trade (RTGS) | Net (end of batch) | |
|---|---|---|
| Strength | Real-time finality; limits systemic risk | Smaller money and securities movements; eases liquidity pressure |
| Weakness | Full liquidity needed for each trade; can cause gridlock if deliveries do not move quickly enough | A participant's true exposure may only show at the end of the batch; a default can force a whole series of trades to be unwound unless collateral covers intra-day exposure |
2.7 Netted settlement and CNS
▼Bilateral vs multilateral netting LO 2.2.5
| Bilateral | Multilateral | |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Two counterparties, same security | Any number of counterparties, same security |
| Result | One transfer between the pair; if only cash is netted there is one cash transfer but securities move separately | Each participant makes one cash or securities transfer per security, to a counterparty or the central clearing system |
| Requirement | Separate netting agreement with each counterparty | A central clearing system to compute obligations and instruct settlement agents and the CSD |
- 1 Securities: +7,000 (bought) − 4,200 − 2,000 (sold) = +800 shares, so BCD receives 800 shares.
- 2 Cash: pays £28,000 on the purchase; receives £17,220 + £7,600 = £24,820 on the sales.
- 3 Net cash = 24,820 − 28,000 = −£3,180, so BCD pays £3,180.
- 4 Instead of three trade-by-trade settlements, BCD has one securities transfer and one cash transfer with the CCP.
- 1 Shares: +5,000 − 3,000 − 1,000 = +1,000 (receive 1,000).
- 2 Cash: receipts 12,300 + 4,100 = 16,400; payment 20,000.
- 3 Net = 16,400 − 20,000 = −3,600, so pays £3,600.
- 4 Method: sign every leg from the firm's point of view (buy = securities in, cash out; sell = the reverse), then add each column. This mirrors the bank question with 7,000 / 4,000 / 2,500 shares, where the answer is receive 500 shares and pay £1,850.
Trade date netting vs continuous net settlement LO 2.2.5
Trade date netting: each firm settles one net cash and one net securities balance calculated at close of business on trade date. It covers only trades flagged for netting that day and excludes failed trades brought forward. Continuous net settlement (CNS): failed trades from earlier days can be re-presented for netting in a later multilateral cycle.
CNS rules: for securities, the algorithm nets opposite-signed positions with the oldest positions first; the net quantity is always kept in the position with the bigger quantity, regardless of intended settlement date (ISD). Cash follows the same idea: the net amount stays in the position with the bigger absolute cash amount.
- 1 Oldest first. POS1 (−40) nets against POS4 (+90): POS1 becomes 0 and the balance sits in the bigger one, POS4 = +50. Cash: +300 − 1,200 leaves POS4 = −€900.
- 2 POS2 (−5) nets against POS4 (+50): POS2 = 0, POS4 = +45. Cash: +10 − 900 leaves POS4 = −€890.
- 3 POS3 (−100) nets against POS4 (+45): the bigger quantity is POS3, so POS4 = 0 and POS3 = −55. Cash: +1,000 − 890 leaves POS3 = +€110.
- 4 Final: a single position of −55 shares and +€110 (the firm still owes 55 shares and is due €110). Check: shares −40 − 5 − 100 + 90 = −55, and cash 300 + 10 + 1,000 − 1,200 = +110.
2.8 Title, book entry, CSDA/ASDA and DLT
▼Physical settlement to book entry; rolling settlement LO 2.2.5
Under physical settlement certificates were exchanged for cash. Where certificates are immobilised, they stay in the CSD vault while book entries debit the seller and credit the buyer. Dematerialisation removes the certificate altogether (ESES holds securities dematerialised). Benefits: greater automation of trading, clearing, settlement and asset servicing; shorter settlement timing; better security against loss, theft or fraud. It needs a matching legal framework protecting ownership records and business continuity procedures for electronic records. In the EU, CSDR requires securities traded on regulated markets or MTFs to be dematerialised.
Rolling settlement: settlement occurs a fixed number of business days after trade date (T+2 in the UK, EU and Australia). The shorter the gap, the fewer outstanding trades and the lower the aggregate market exposure.
Transfer of legal title LO 2.2.6
| Bearer | Registered (certificated) | Registered (dematerialised) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typically held as | Certificate and book entry | Register and certificate | Register and book entry |
| Transfer method | Book-entry transfer | Transfer and reregistration | Book entry and reregistration |
| Holder named on register? | No | Yes | Yes |
- Bearer: stored at the local CSD or sometimes the custodian, which records total holdings and each investor's share but usually not certificate numbers, so bearer securities are fungible like banknotes. Holders carry the loss/theft risk. If buyer and seller both have accounts at the CSD (or the same custodian), title moves by book entry with certificates staying in the vault.
- Registered, certificated: the seller completes a transfer form; the registrar cancels the old certificate and issues a new one in the buyer's name, after any transfer tax.
- Registered, dematerialised: the CSD notifies the registrar electronically and the register is updated. The stock can be traded again as soon as it settles, unlike certificated stock where issuing a new certificate causes delay.
ASDA vs CSDA LO 2.2.7
| ASDA (actual settlement date accounting) | CSDA (contractual settlement date accounting) | |
|---|---|---|
| When cash is credited/debited | On the date the trade actually settles | On the contractual (or pre-agreed value) date, even if settlement is not yet final |
| If settlement is late | Seller loses the use of and interest on funds; buyer gains (pays later) | Client gets certainty over cash flows |
| Who bears risk | The delayed party bears the cost | The custodian, which extends provisional credit |
Example from the workbook: a trade due T+2 that actually settles T+5 leaves the seller without funds for three days under ASDA. CSDA is usually offered only in well-structured, liquid markets, is specified in the SLA, may not apply (or may be withdrawn) if the seller's stock is not available, and requires the custodian to monitor late settlements and reverse provisional credits where appropriate. Clients must understand credits are provisional, or they may understate exposure or face an overdraft on reversal.
FinTech and distributed ledger technology LO 2.2.8
Fintech is technology that automates or improves financial services (the workbook notes it is not new: credit cards in the 1950s, ATMs, electronic trading floors). DLT is a shared ledger synchronised across multiple sites, countries or institutions with no central register or authority; each copy is an exact copy, updated independently while updating the others, secured by cryptographic keys and signatures. Blockchain is one type of DLT (used by Bitcoin): data is added in blocks, each permanently chained to the previous one.
Claimed benefits: cost efficiency, faster and more effective settlement and registration, and near-immunity to cybercrime because every copy would have to be attacked at once. Example: Euroclear with the European Investment Bank, Banco Santander and EY built an end-to-end blockchain solution for issuing and settling European commercial paper.
2.9 FX settlement
▼Reading an FX quote LO 2.2.5
FX is used to obtain currency for payments, to hedge, and to speculate. A quote such as GBP/USD 1.2988-92 means: first currency = base, second = quoted; one unit of base buys the amount of quoted currency. The first price is the bid and the second is the offer (only the last two digits are shown, so the offer is 1.2992). The spread is the offer minus the bid (the trader's margin) and the mid-price is their average. FX is not exchange-traded: banks deal directly, by phone or electronically.
- 1 Bid = 1.2988; offer = 1.2992 (the quote shows only the last two digits).
- 2 Spread = 1.2992 − 1.2988 = 0.0004. Mid-price = (1.2988 + 1.2992) / 2 = 1.2990.
- 3 Per the workbook definition, the first price (bid) is what you obtain when buying the second currency with the first, so £1,000,000 gives 1,000,000 × 1.2988 = US$1,298,800.
- 4 The offer runs the other way: US$1,299,200 is needed to buy £1,000,000 (1.2992 × 1,000,000).
Spot, forward, swap, NDF, option LO 2.2.5
| Instrument | Definition |
|---|---|
| Spot | Single outright exchange at a rate agreed now; settles within two business days |
| Outright forward | Settlement more than two days ahead; no standard dates; rate fixed at deal date, no money changes hands until settlement |
| FX swap | Simultaneous purchase and sale of a currency for two different settlement dates: one spot and one forward deal, with a single counterparty. Most forwards are done as swaps |
| Non-deliverable forward (NDF) | Rate set for a future date but the quoted currency is not exchanged; the rate is compared with the prevailing spot and only the profit or loss is settled. Used to speculate without reversing, or where dealing restrictions exist (workbook example: Brazil registration and a 2% finance tax on international transfers above BRL10,000) |
| FX option | Right but not obligation to deal at a set rate, usually in future; the buyer pays a premium to the writer |
Global turnover per the BIS 2022 survey: about US$7.2 trillion a day, of which roughly 28% spot, 51% swaps, 15% outright forwards and 4% options. The workbook states that spot-rate drivers, purchasing power parity, cross rates and forward-rate/interest-rate-parity calculations are for information only and will not be examined; the only takeaway is that a forward rate reflects the interest rate difference between the two currencies, not a forecast.
Herstatt risk and CLS LO 2.2.4
Herstatt risk is the risk that in an FX trade one leg is paid and the counterparty fails before paying the other. It is named for Bankhaus Herstatt, whose German licence was withdrawn in June 1974 after the German interbank payment system closed: it had received Deutschmark payments, but its New York correspondent, just opening as the news broke, would not release the US dollars.
CLS removes it by acting as intermediary: both parties pay in to accounts at CLS Bank, and only when both are fully paid in does CLS pay out. If one side fails to pay in, it receives no pay-out and the other side's funds are returned. Before CLS each side was paid separately, and time-zone differences widened the risk.
2.10 Failed settlement and CSDR discipline
▼Why trades fail and what it costs LO 2.3.1, 2.3.2
| Reason | Examples |
|---|---|
| Non-matching instructions | Incorrect or incomplete details, a dispute, or no instruction submitted |
| Insufficient securities | Seller unable or unwilling to borrow; awaiting delivery of its own purchase; securities out on loan and not recalled |
| Insufficient funds | Buyer waiting for sale proceeds or facing a funding problem |
| Corporate actions | Clearing organisation blocks delivery, eg shares blocked for days before a shareholder vote |
| Counterparty default | Counterparty in liquidation |
Penalties vary by market: interest claims, fines, suspension of trading, short-sale fines, and reputational damage. A buyer who cannot pay is likely to be charged penalty interest and may face a buy-in.
Buy-ins and sell-outs LO 2.3.2
| Buy-in | Sell-out | |
|---|---|---|
| Who fails | The seller fails to deliver securities | The buyer fails to deliver cash |
| What happens | Buyer (or CCP/exchange) gives notice, then buys the securities from a third party at market price | Seller (able to deliver) gives notice, then sells the securities to another buyer; proceeds cover the cash leg |
| Extra costs | Difference between buy-in price and original price, plus fees, passed to the failing seller | Extra costs of raising the funds passed to the failing buyer |
| Use | Common | Never widely used |
Either procedure may be started by the firm or market authorities under local rules; in some markets it is automatic (in Singapore trades unsettled at SD+1 are posted on a buy-in board). Firms often use stock borrowing to cover a shortfall and avoid a buy-in or fine.
Fines: EUI and the US LO 2.3.2
Matching fines (Euroclear UK & International, from 1 September 2014): firms must match all trades by close of business on T+1. A fine of £4.00 per unmatched transaction at close of T+1, plus £2.00 for each further day unmatched, for up to 30 local business days, after which the instruction is automatically cancelled in CREST.
| Settlement-rate target (over a two-month period) | Required |
|---|---|
| Settle on SD | 85% |
| By SD+1 | 90% |
| By each of SD+2 to SD+9 | 95% |
| By each of SD+10 to SD+15 | 98% |
| By each of SD+16 to SD+20 | 99% |
Settlement fines for failed deliveries are calculated only up to 20 local business days after the contractual settlement date.
US: the New York Fed's Treasury Market Practice Group advises fails charges for US Treasuries, agency debt and agency MBS. For inter-dealer Treasury and agency debt trades, FICC calculates fines automatically and applies them to members' monthly bills; where a party is not a FICC member the non-failing party claims. The recommended minimum claim is US$500.
- 1 Initial fine for being unmatched at close of T+1: £4.00.
- 2 Additional £2.00 for each subsequent day: 4 days × £2.00 = £8.00.
- 3 Total = £4.00 + £8.00 = £12.00 per transaction (the workbook wording does not spell out day-counting edge cases, so treat this as the intended reading).
CSDR settlement discipline LO 2.3.4
CSDR aims to harmonise settlement discipline across the EU, cut fails and stop markets competing on weaker penalty regimes. Measures: rules on trade allocation and confirmation, cash penalties on failed transactions, mandatory buy-ins, and monitoring and reporting of fails. Implementation was postponed (COVID-19) so it came into force in February 2022, while mandatory buying-in has been deferred until November 2025. The UK onshored CSDR but will not implement the settlement discipline regime, described as an early example of post-Brexit divergence.
2.11 Interest claims
▼The ICMA interest claim formula LO 2.3.3
If a buyer (or its clearing agent) causes a settlement to fail, the seller normally claims for the interest it lost on the net amount it would have received. ICMA sets the rules and recommendations for fixed income; ICMA members are bound by them.
- Overdraft rate: the rate applicable to the seller at its agent bank (the actual overdraft rate incurred).
- Day basis: whatever the cash market of the settlement currency uses for overdrafts: 365/366 for GBP, 360 for many other currencies.
- The buyer has 15 days to dispute the claim or 30 days to pay it. Grounds for dispute include a disagreement over the number of days or an overdraft rate well above the published borrowing rate.
- Claims under US$500 (or equivalent) are written off; claims are not paid if 30 calendar days have elapsed since the actual settlement date; no additional administration costs may be claimed.
- 1 Interest for a full year at 4%: 219,000 × 4/100 = £8,760.
- 2 Scale to 5 days: 8,760 × 5/365 = £120.00.
- 1 Case 1: 150,000 × 5/100 = 7,500 a year; × 6/365 = 123.29. Claim £123.29 (rounded to the penny).
- 2 Case 2: 200,000 × 3/100 = 6,000 a year; × 4/360 = 66.67. Claim 66.67 in that currency.
- 3 Then apply the US$500 rule: both claims are far below the threshold, so in practice they would be written off. The calculation is still what the exam asks for; the write-off is the extra trap.
2.12 Ch 2 cheat sheet
▼All the numbers + names
| Item | Answer |
|---|---|
| Trade cycle | Trading · pre-settlement/clearing · settlement · post-settlement |
| Novation | CCP becomes buyer to every seller and seller to every buyer |
| Clearing members | ICM own only · GCM own + others · NCM uses a GCM |
| MarketAxess Post-Trade | ICMA, 1989, ex-TRAX (acquired 2013) |
| OSTTRA | CME + IHS Markit, 1 Sep 2021 |
| Transaction reporting | MiFID II/MiFIR from 3 Jan 2018 · via ARM · T+1 |
| Settlement periods | Most T+2 · T+1: US, India, UK gilts, JGBs · T+0: Brazil debt, HK debt (CMU), Korea debt |
| ADR | US$ · T+1 · vote yes, rights issue no · 1.5% issue charge on UK/Irish shares |
| DR pre-release | Shares due within ~3 months · fully collateralised |
| DI | Foreign share settled in CREST · SDRT-exempt |
| CHIPS / Fedwire | US$ netting with pre-funding / US$ RTGS (Fed) |
| CHAPS / TARGET2 | Sterling RTGS (06:00-18:00) / euro RTGS (Nov 2007; 07:00-18:00 CET) |
| CLS | FX PvP · removes Herstatt risk · settlement member vs user member |
| DvP ways | RTGS · netting with end-of-day finality · CSD books · guaranteed cheque |
| CREST DvP | Model 1 · simultaneous, irrevocable · central bank money |
| Multilateral netting | Sign each leg, add securities and cash separately |
| CNS | Re-presents fails · oldest first · net kept in bigger position |
| ASDA / CSDA | Actual date (seller loses on delay) / contractual date (custodian provisional credit) |
| FX quote | Bid (first) · offer (second) · spread · mid |
| Spot / forward | Within 2 business days / more than 2 days |
| Buy-in / sell-out | Seller fails / buyer fails; cost to failing party |
| EUI matching fine | £4 at close T+1, +£2/day, max 30 days (from 1 Sep 2014) |
| EUI settlement targets | 85% SD · 90% SD+1 · 95% SD+2-9 · 98% SD+10-15 · 99% SD+16-20 |
| CSDR discipline | In force Feb 2022 · mandatory buy-ins deferred to Nov 2025 · UK not implementing |
| Interest claim | Net × rate/100 × days/360-or-365 · dispute 15 days · pay 30 days · write off under US$500 |