1.1 Ethics in practice: the four-principle test
▼The four ethical principles syllabus 1.1.1
Ethics in practice simply means doing the right thing, and it involves your own choice. Words like values, integrity and morals are often used alongside it. When the right answer is not obvious, the workbook gives you one question to ask yourself:
| Principle | Ask yourself | Workbook's lost-phone example |
|---|---|---|
| Honest | Am I being truthful about what is and is not mine? | The phone is not yours, so keeping it is not honest |
| Open | Did I make an attempt to do this in the open, e.g. ask around? | Did you ask anyone nearby or try to find the owner? |
| Transparent | Would I be comfortable explaining this to others? | Could you tell friends how you got your "new" phone? |
| Fair | Does this deprive someone else or bypass the proper process? | Keeping it deprives the owner and ignores the proper route for lost property |
The point of the example: something that first looks harmless (you did not steal it, you found it) quickly looks unethical once you run it through the four tests.
Ethics vs the law syllabus 1.1.1
Ethics, regulation and the law are related but not identical. The relationship only works in one direction:
| Situation | Illegal? | Unethical? |
|---|---|---|
| Behaviour that is antisocial or harmful but not against any law | No | Yes, it can be |
| Breaking the law | Yes | Yes, it is both illegal and unethical |
So "it was legal" is not a complete defence of a decision. The workbook also tackles the common argument that ignoring ethics brings short-term benefits. Its answer: self-interested, unethical behaviour is rarely sustainable, and the negative consequences (from social disapproval up to formal legal sanctions) almost always outweigh the short-term gain.
1.2 Ethics in financial services and selling
▼Why trust matters: the Wells Fargo example syllabus 1.1.1
Unethical conduct has been especially damaging in financial services because the whole industry rests on trust, and trust is far easier to lose than to rebuild. The workbook uses Wells Fargo, a large US bank, as its example of how a toxic culture can drive widespread unethical behaviour.
- What happened: the bank was found in 2016 to have opened millions of accounts without customers' knowledge or consent.
- Why: an aggressive, target-driven sales culture with unrealistic goals and heavy incentives; staff cut corners to protect their jobs.
- Scale (as at the workbook, Edition 7): between 2011 and 2016, over three million unauthorised current, savings and credit card accounts were allegedly created in existing customers' names, generating extra fees and boosting sales figures at the customers' expense.
- Consequences: the CEO and several senior executives resigned, the bank agreed to pay $3 billion to resolve potential civil and criminal liabilities, and the reputational damage spread across the wider industry.
Lesson to remember: pressure to hit short-term targets plus a weak culture leads to failure to be honest, open, transparent and fair, and the long-term, sector-wide cost is far bigger than the short-term sales gain.
Ethical vs unethical selling syllabus 1.1.1
Selling financial products carries special ethical risk because they are complex, intangible and long term. Compare a car: you can see it, drive it, check it works, and it has a warranty. You cannot test-drive a pension, an investment or a mortgage; its performance unfolds over years or decades. That puts more responsibility on the seller.
| An ETHICAL salesperson... | An UNETHICAL salesperson may... |
|---|---|
| Explains the structure and purpose of the product | Avoids answering questions ("no one else has asked me that") |
| Outlines the risks, not just the benefits | Uses vague reassurance ("I wouldn't sell something I didn't believe in") |
| Says whether returns are guaranteed or only anticipated | Deflects responsibility ("we have rocket scientists who design these") |
| Acknowledges factors outside the provider's control | Pushes artificial urgency ("limited-time offer, decide now") |
| Discloses any commission or incentive received | Lets the customer act without understanding what they are buying |
The aim of ethical selling: the customer has everything they need to make an informed decision.
The CISI restatement: spelling C-I-S-I syllabus 1.1.1
The CISI (Chartered Institute for Securities and Investment) recommends that members use the four principles when the right course of action is unclear. It restates each principle with a second descriptive word, so that the first letters spell CISI:
| Original principle | CISI restatement | Letter |
|---|---|---|
| Honest | Clear and honest | C |
| Open | Impartial and open | I |
| Transparent | Straightforward and transparent | S |
| Fair | Informed and fair | I |
1.3 ESG: environmental, social and governance
▼What ESG measures syllabus 1.1.2
ESG stands for Environmental, Social and Governance. It looks at whether a company behaves responsibly, not only financially but in its impact on the planet, on people and in how it is run. It is closely linked to ethics. Governance is often called corporate governance when applied to companies.
| Letter | Theme | Typical criteria in the workbook |
|---|---|---|
| E Environmental | The planet | Energy use and efficiency; minimising waste and pollution; protecting natural resources and reducing environmental harm |
| S Social | People and community | Support for the local community; charitable giving; employee health, safety and wellbeing; ethical standards for suppliers (working conditions, treatment of staff) |
| G Governance | How the company is run | Diversity of leadership (age, experience, ethnicity, gender); balance between executive and non-executive directors; ethical expectations of staff, especially senior managers |
A quick way to tell directors apart: executive directors run the business day to day; non-executive directors give independent oversight.
1.4 Responsible and impact investing
▼Responsible investment syllabus 1.1.2
Responsible investment means combining financial objectives with values: bringing ESG considerations into the investment decision. The investor may still mainly want to grow their money, but also wants investments that line up with certain ethical or environmental standards. What counts as "responsible" varies from investor to investor.
- Avoiding harmful activities: some investors exclude companies they believe cause environmental or social harm. The workbook's examples are tobacco, gambling, alcohol production and weapons manufacturing.
- Financial benefits: companies that behave responsibly may become more attractive to customers, employees and investors, so they may perform better over time. Responsible investing can therefore potentially lead to stronger long-term returns as well as positive societal outcomes.
Impact investing, gender lens and microfinance syllabus 1.1.3
Impact investing goes one step further than responsible investment. Rather than only avoiding harm, the investor deliberately directs money at companies that deliver social or environmental benefits (e.g. clean energy or organic food). It seeks both a financial return and a positive contribution.
| Type | What it does |
|---|---|
| Gender lens investing | Supports gender equality and opportunities for women: capital for women starting or growing businesses; products and services that benefit women and girls; better gender balance on boards and in the workforce; equal working conditions and pay |
| Microfinance | Helps low-income people or those with limited access to conventional finance, often in developing countries. Typically small loans (microloans) combined with financial or business education, helping sole traders, family firms and small cooperatives become more stable, buy essential equipment and avoid exploitative moneylenders |
| Responsible investment | Impact investing | |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Consider ESG; often exclude harmful sectors | Deliberately fund positive outcomes |
| Example | Not buying tobacco or weapons companies | Funding a clean-energy firm or a microfinance lender |
1.5 Ch 1 cheat sheet
▼All the names and lists syllabus 1.1.1 - 1.1.3
| Item | Answer |
|---|---|
| Four principles | Honest · Open · Transparent · Fair |
| The test question | "Is what I am about to do honest, open, transparent and fair?" |
| Ethics vs law | Can be unethical without being illegal; illegal is always unethical too |
| CISI restatement | Clear and honest · Impartial and open · Straightforward and transparent · Informed and fair |
| Wells Fargo | Accounts opened without consent · target-driven culture · 2011-2016 · over 3 million accounts · $3 billion |
| Ethical seller | Explains, shows risks, says if returns are guaranteed, discloses commission |
| Unethical seller | Dodges questions · vague reassurance · deflects · artificial urgency |
| ESG | Environmental · Social · Governance |
| Environmental examples | Energy efficiency · waste and pollution · natural resources |
| Social examples | Community · charity · employee wellbeing · supplier standards |
| Governance examples | Board diversity · executive vs non-executive balance · staff ethical expectations |
| Responsible investment | ESG in decisions · exclusions such as tobacco, gambling, alcohol, weapons |
| Impact investing | Financial return AND positive impact · gender lens · microfinance |