1.1 Risk vs uncertainty and the simple framework
▼What risk is, and what risk management does syllabus 1.1.1 - 1.1.2
In its broadest sense, risk is the possible harm associated with a situation: the product of impact and probability. Risk management is the practice of using processes, methods and tools to quantify and manage risks and uncertainties. It focuses on three things: identifying what could go wrong, evaluating which risks should be dealt with, and implementing strategies to address them.
Managing financial risk for customers and owners is one of the core reasons a financial services firm exists, which is why risk is central to the whole syllabus. Firms that identify risks in advance and hold a response plan are better prepared and deal with events more cost-effectively.
Risk vs uncertainty syllabus 1.1.2
| Term | Meaning | Where the data exists |
|---|---|---|
| Risk | Variability that CAN be quantified in terms of probabilities | Credit and market risk: large amounts of observable, repeating data can be grouped and analysed |
| Uncertainty | Variability that cannot be quantified at all | Strategic and operational risk: events are often unique, so far less repeatable data |
The distinction is technical. It should not stop a firm protecting itself against the negative consequences of less quantifiable events.
A simple risk framework syllabus 1.1.2
| Element | Who does it | What it involves |
|---|---|---|
| Risk policies and governance | Board level | Sets the policy and governance backdrop |
| Risk oversight | Independent risk management function (second line), with results and action plans reported to and agreed with it by the business unit | Identify, assess, ensure risks are appropriately controlled, monitor and report on risks and their controls |
| Day-to-day risk management | Business units (first line) | Inseparable from good business management; must be owned by the business, not by the risk function |
The risk function is often organised by risk type. The workbook also refers to internal and external auditors as a third line of defence.
The big picture: seven building blocks chapter overview
The workbook opens with a diagram of a firm in its risk environment. Read it as seven items:
| Block | Idea |
|---|---|
| Credit, market, liquidity risk | At the centre because managing them is the heart of the industry's complex financial transactions |
| Investment risk | The combination of risks involved in providing the "right" level of return to investors |
| Operational risk | The act of managing the above is itself risky: people, processes, systems and external events are the four key drivers |
| Enterprise risk | Risk information grouped and reported collectively (the "risk equivalent" of the balance sheet, P&L and cash flow statement) so the senior team can make firm-wide decisions |
| Strategic risk (internal) | Drivers: chosen strategy, translating it into an operating model, financial management, internal compliance with external rules |
| Strategic risk (external) | Unforeseen changes in the global economy, politics, competition, social and market forces, and technology |
| Corporate governance and risk oversight | Strategic risk-takers (CEO, directors, senior managers) set which risks to take or avoid; tactical risk-takers (traders, asset managers, analysts) implement |
Firms keep a risk register of risk types and specific risks so that risks and their mitigating actions and controls can be understood, owned and monitored. They then decide how much risk to take (risk appetite) and use formal controls, high-quality reporting and a sound risk culture to make sure it is not exceeded.
1.2 External sources of risk + how they are assessed
▼The external sources syllabus 1.1.3
| Source | What the workbook says |
|---|---|
| Economic | Firms must understand current and future patterns of human behaviour. Example: failing to foresee a downturn leaves a firm building stock at boom-time input prices and then cutting prices in a recession; securitised mortgages are hard to sell if house prices fall |
| Political | A change of government, economic policy or tax law can (1) move the markets firms invest in, (2) change demand for the industry's products, (3) change the legislative and regulatory environment |
| Competitive environment, social and market forces | A competitor gaining critical mass may force others out of a segment; a failing competitor may create chances to buy business cheaply. Social and market forces include technology advances, consumer behaviour, wealth inequality, propensity to save, attitudes to living on credit, house prices vs demographics |
| Technological, incl. cyber | Firms that do not keep up risk becoming obsolete. Cyber risk = theft of, or damage to, information stored on or exchanged between computers, and the systems and websites on them. It must be managed proactively by the board, led by senior management |
| Shocks and natural events | Local events can hit the national or global economy. Workbook examples: the 2010 Icelandic volcano eruption (airline loss around US$1.7bn per IATA), the Russian invasion of Ukraine (supply chains, inflation, energy), COVID-19 |
| External stakeholders and third parties | Parent company, major institutional investors, large customers; plus regulators, brokers, solicitors, IT and data suppliers, outsourced back-office administrators, advisers |
| ESG | See the next block |
Stakeholder and third-party risk syllabus 1.1.3
| Stakeholder | Why it is a risk |
|---|---|
| Parent company | Takes a "broader" view across its businesses and may question or change the subsidiary's plans, often after staff are hired and research commissioned |
| Institutional investors | Large holdings give voting influence (e.g. shareholder resolutions, lobbying) and the firm may be unable to stop them pushing for change |
| Large customers | Over-reliance is a concentration risk; over time the firm should dilute it by widening its customer base |
Managing stakeholder risk: build senior-level relationships, understand the stakeholder's agenda and how it differs from yours, manage expectations as developments arise. For third parties, ensure where possible that equivalent goods and services can be sourced from alternative suppliers, so a default or delay does not interrupt customer service.
ESG risks: environmental, social, governance syllabus 1.1.3
| Type | Emanates from |
|---|---|
| Environmental | Climate change (firms' vulnerability to it) and depletion of natural resources (water scarcity, land use, raw-material sourcing) |
| Social | Human capital (labour management, health and safety), product liability (safety, quality, privacy, data safety), stakeholder opposition (local health and demographic risks, controversial sourcing) |
| Governance | Corporate governance (management structure, board-employee relations, compensation) and corporate behaviour (ethics, anti-competitive practices, tax, transparency, corruption, financial system instability) |
The workbook stresses that ESG is not only a long-horizon issue: its example is PG&E, California's largest utility, declaring bankruptcy after billions of dollars of claims from the 2017 and 2018 wildfires. Impacts can be direct financial costs, missed opportunities (new products, cost savings) or larger secondary impacts spread across the business, such as lawsuits. The COSO Framework argues ESG should be integrated into enterprise-wide risk management, and boards should ask whether risk identification covers ESG risks over the short, medium and long term.
Assessing external risk: PESTLE, BCP, business process analysis syllabus 1.1.4
| Technique | What it is |
|---|---|
| PESTLE analysis | Analysis of the external macro environment, often a brainstorm with internal and external experts. Headings: Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal, Environmental. Includes factors beyond the firm's control that it should still know about |
| Business continuity planning | Planning for disaster recovery and continuity itself uncovers external risk factors |
| Business process analysis | Examine each high-level business process, describing both the internal low-level processes and the external factors that can influence them |
1.3 Internal drivers of risk + how they are assessed
▼Strategic, operational and financial risk syllabus 1.1.5
| Driver | Definition / test |
|---|---|
| Strategic risk | The workbook quotes the European Banking Authority: current or prospective risk to earnings and capital from changes in the business environment, adverse business decisions, improper implementation of decisions, or lack of responsiveness. In simple terms, two questions: (1) Is the strategy right? (2) Is it being properly implemented? |
| Operational risk | BIS: the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems, or from external events |
| Financial risk | Commonly credit, market and liquidity risk |
The three financial risks in one line each: credit = loss from a counterparty or issuer failing to meet its obligation; market = loss from changes in the value of financial instruments; liquidity = insufficient cash to meet cash obligations, leading to insolvency or losses from borrowing, selling assets below market price, or paying contractual penalties.
Assessing internal risk: workshops, auditors, stress tests, scenarios syllabus 1.1.6
| Technique | How the workbook describes it |
|---|---|
| Risk assessment workshops | Walk through corporate goals, processes, services or products to bring out risk factors that could prevent success or continuation |
| Discussion with internal and external auditors | Auditors provide a third line of defence on potential areas of risk |
| Stress testing | Varying one input factor at a time, e.g. seeing what different costs of capital across business units would do |
| Scenario analysis | Constructing realistic scenarios, perhaps based on past extreme events, to question the current situation, e.g. applying the conditions of a previous major IT failure to a business plan and observing the effect on break-even if customer payments could not be made on time |
Internal and external drivers overlap syllabus 1.1.7
External forces often give rise to internal risks, so the two must be addressed simultaneously. The workbook's example is launching a new product: internal risks (strategic, operational, compliance, financial) plus external ones (especially the economic climate and competitive environment). Ways to reduce the business risk of a launch:
- gap analysis of the firm's strategy
- market surveys to establish external demand
- market research on similar competitor products
- research and development to design the product
- liaison with external stakeholders, such as the regulator
- "test marketing" to fine-tune the product and launch
1.4 Risk terminology
▼Risk culture and conduct risk syllabus 1.1.8
Risk culture is the system of values and behaviours throughout an organisation that shape risk decisions, influencing people even when they are not consciously weighing risk and benefit. Features of a healthy culture: the board and senior team's attitude to risk and ethics; how well that is communicated; the degree to which risk is formally considered in decisions; and how far incentive schemes reinforce good risk management.
Conduct risk is the risk that the firm's behaviour will result in poor outcomes for customers. It is one manifestation of poor risk culture: the firm enriches itself at the customer's expense, putting profit ahead of the customer. The workbook cites the FCA's Consumer Duty (effective July 2023), under which firms, including senior managers and boards, are held accountable for good consumer outcomes. Market failures such as a lack of decision-making information, often made worse by low consumer financial capability, also contribute.
Risk appetite syllabus 1.1.8
Risk appetite (or risk tolerance) is the type and amount of risk a firm is willing to accept in pursuit of its business objectives. It is expressed differently by risk type:
| Risk kind | How appetite is expressed |
|---|---|
| Easily quantifiable | An appetite level for direct financial loss, or specific measures such as credit or market Value-at-Risk (VaR) |
| Less quantifiable | Non-financial statements, e.g. re-open within eight hours after loss of main premises; "no appetite" for misselling risk |
Setting appetite is iterative and needs both approaches:
| Approach | Who | What |
|---|---|---|
| Top-down | Board and senior management | Identify threats to objectives; relate them to available coverage from capital, earnings and assets; recognise capital is not always the best mitigant; use scenario analysis to devise responses |
| Bottom-up | Line management | Departmental "acceptable occurrence" levels for errors and losses; key risk indicators (KRIs) tracked against pre-defined appetites |
An escalation mechanism for breaches (e.g. via risk appetite statements) links the two. At group level, the firm's risk profile is in effect its current default risk appetite, tied to the risk capital available.
Inherent (gross) vs residual (net) risk syllabus 1.1.8
| Term | Also called | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Inherent risk | Gross risk | Risk assessed WITHOUT the beneficial effect of mitigating controls. It matters because it is the exposure if controls fail, though it is not necessarily the maximum possible risk (staff effort and honesty often "keep the show on the road") |
| Residual risk | Net risk | Exposure AFTER mitigating controls. May not be zero because getting there could be too expensive or not even possible |
Risk profile, risk mitigation, reputational risk syllabus 1.1.8
| Term | Key points |
|---|---|
| Risk profile | The type and intensity of risks a firm is exposed to: the nature of the threats, the likelihood of adverse effects, and the level of disruption and cost of each type |
| Risk mitigation | Efforts to reduce the impact, the likelihood, or both. Examples: insurance; upgrading processes and IT (operational risk); hedging (market risk); holding collateral (credit risk), an asset of the borrower that the lender can liquidate if the loan is not repaid |
| Reputational risk | Either an outcome itself or a direct or indirect consequence of other risk classes (market, credit, liquidity, operational). It can cause or magnify other risks, e.g. loss of reputation leading to liquidity or business risks, particularly in banking |
Ways reputational damage causes losses: loss of current or future customers; loss of employees or managers, higher hiring costs or staff downtime; loss of business partners; higher funding costs in credit or equity markets; higher costs from regulation, fines or penalties.
1.5 Adding value + the BIS risk types + interconnectedness
▼How risk management protects and adds value syllabus 1.1.9
New ventures are usually justified with a cost/benefit analysis comparing likely revenue with cost, but the risk the venture creates is sometimes overlooked by the business sponsor. Some risks, such as regulatory risk or client litigation, can dwarf the operational cost of supporting the venture. If risk staff are involved from the start, they can advise on likelihood and impact early enough that mitigation is built into the solution.
Day to day, good risk management reduces unexpected outcomes, which tends to reduce earnings volatility and therefore enhance the share price. Stakeholders also benefit: customers get more consistent service, regulators see a more predictable firm, and the firm avoids bad publicity.
The BIS key risk areas syllabus 1.2.1
| Risk | Workbook definition |
|---|---|
| Operational | Loss from inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems, or from external events |
| Credit | Loss from failure of a counterparty or issuer to meet its obligations. Present across the industry but most important for banks, since lending is their core activity and loans make up the bulk of assets |
| Market | Loss from changes in the value of financial instruments |
| Asset liquidity | Allied with market risk: being unable to unwind a position at or near market value because of a lack of depth or disruption in the market for that instrument |
| Funding liquidity | The firm cannot obtain the funds needed to meet its obligations as they fall due |
| Interest rate | Exposure of financial condition to adverse interest rate movements; arises from specific fixed-rate products or from the overall balance sheet structure |
Risk interconnectedness syllabus 1.2.2
- Risks often happen at the same time or cause one another.
- Interest rate, market and asset liquidity, and funding liquidity risks are positively correlated with GDP growth: they increase when activity is growing.
- Operational and credit risks tend to increase when GDP growth slows: more defaults and operational losses in a downturn.
- The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision has shown that risks interact non-linearly. Default-induced credit losses can be driven by market price changes and factors such as interest rates, FX and commodity prices, while price changes depend on rating migration or a rise in perceived default risk.
- Example: the 2007/08 crisis, where the credit quality of US subprime mortgage debt became a global issue and credit risk became a liquidity issue.
1.6 Systemic risk + recovery and resolution
▼Contagion and systemic risk syllabus 1.2.3
Because firms across the sector interact closely, a risk affecting one firm or group can threaten the stability of the whole system. This spreading is contagion and it creates systemic risk. Workbook examples: the widespread run on US banks in the early 1930s after the Wall Street Crash, and the liquidity crisis that began in 2007 and became a global credit crisis in 2008-09.
If depositors fear a bank might fail, even wrongly, they withdraw en masse, which can cause the failure and leave too little to repay slower depositors. The workbook says deposit insurance schemes have reduced this risk.
| Firm type | Effect of failure | Regulatory attitude |
|---|---|---|
| Bank | Implications for client deposits AND the international payment systems | Often work with government to keep it operating |
| Investment manager / securities firm | May involve no client loss; the value of money circulating is unchanged | May be allowed to fail |
When a government takes on its banks' debts, a new risk emerges: sovereign default risk. If the state guarantees its banking system but cannot honour the guarantee, it may in extremis default on its government bonds. A challenge for regulators: systemic risk may be highest when individual firms' measured risk is lowest, because low measured risk encourages behaviour that builds systemic risk.
Recovery and resolution plans syllabus 1.2.3
In jurisdictions such as the UK, regulators require banks and larger investment firms to maintain recovery and resolution plans setting out:
- credible recovery actions the firm could take in severe stress to restore a stable and sustainable business, and
- the mechanism for an orderly resolution of any absolute failure.
From the regulator's viewpoint, the aim is that a failed firm can be resolved without severe systemic disruption and without exposing taxpayers to loss, while protecting vital economic functions and imposing losses on bank creditors.
Financial services vs other industries syllabus 1.2.3
Strategic and operational risks affect most industries. Credit, liquidity, market and investment risks also touch other industries to a lesser or greater extent, but are inherent to financial services. Characteristics that set the sector apart: complexity; no physical product; product life spans often measured in decades; and being a necessity of modern economic systems rather than an optional extra.
1.7 Emerging considerations: fintech, regtech, crypto
▼Fintech and Regtech syllabus 1.3.1
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Fintech | "Financial" + "technology": companies using technology to improve the efficiency of financial processes and automate delivery and use of services. No standard definition. Can change business models and the competitive landscape |
| Regtech | A combination of regulation and technology, emerging because of rapid fintech change and the flood of new, complex regulation and reporting. It offers speed and agility in managing those requirements |
Benefits mentioned: some e-money institutions offering better forex rates, digital banks giving real-time insight into personal finances, and AI/machine learning for faster tailored services (e.g. in credit risk, training an algorithm on past decisions of credit approvers). Regulators are challenged to keep pace and are in an ambiguous position: they want to support innovation while watching the emerging risks.
Digital assets, blockchain, smart contracts syllabus 1.3.1
| Concept | Key points |
|---|---|
| Cryptoasset | A digital asset not issued by a central authority and needing no middleman; uses decentralised distributed ledger technology (DLT) |
| Blockchain | The first fully functional DLT: a public ledger that grows as completed blocks of the latest transactions are added in chronological order, letting participants track transactions without central record-keeping |
| Smart contract | Uses code to define and enforce contract rules; once deployed it runs autonomously with no intermediary such as a bank |
| ICO | Initial coin or currency offering: often a form of crowdfunding to raise capital using cryptocurrencies; can let start-ups avoid regulations and intermediaries that would demand scrutiny or a share of future profits |
Risks of crypto assets syllabus 1.3.1
| Risk area | Points from the workbook |
|---|---|
| Regulation / financial crime | Growth driven by individuals and unregulated companies; less regulated than traditional capital markets, so higher fraud, money laundering and terrorist financing risk. No single unified AML approach exists. 4MLD brings virtual assets and e-money into account, with virtual-asset exchange services regulated for AML by member states. The Payment Services Directive (PSD) aims for a safer online payment environment and requires strong customer authentication |
| Cyber security | Exchanges and wallets are hacked; malware; phishing. If wallet keys are stolen the thief has the same access as the owner, and once assets are transferred out and committed to the blockchain they are lost to the original owner |
| Data security | GDPR: fines of 20 million euros or, for an undertaking, up to 4% of total global turnover, whichever is greater. The workbook also lists data protection laws in Hong Kong, Japan, China and Saudi Arabia |
| Custody | Custody means storing the cryptographic keys that control the asset, not simply safekeeping "assets". Whoever holds the private key controls the asset. Hot (online) storage needs strong encryption and separate storage of asset and key; cold (offline) storage has digital and physical risks (vaults and bunkers) |
| Market risk | Drivers of price are less transparent; assets trade only on demand; limited supply and ownership give liquidity concerns and susceptibility to manipulation; high volatility (workbook: Bitcoin fell about 75% peak to trough within a year, 2018 to 2019). FTX's collapse in November 2022 is cited |
| Business and reputational | A "crypto strategy" may dismay existing clients; a negative regulatory event can trigger loss of confidence; any data breach can bring liability, fines and brand damage |
1.8 Ch 1 cheat sheet
▼All the definitions in one table
| Item | Answer |
|---|---|
| Risk | Possible harm: impact x probability |
| Risk vs uncertainty | Quantifiable with probabilities vs cannot be quantified |
| Simple framework | Board: policy/governance · risk function: oversight (identify, assess, control, monitor/report) · business units: day-to-day |
| Operational risk drivers | People, processes, systems, external events |
| Political risk: 3 effects | Markets · demand for products · legislative/regulatory environment |
| Stakeholder examples | Parent company · institutional investors · large customers |
| ESG | Environmental (climate, resources) · Social (human capital, product liability, opposition) · Governance (structure, behaviour) |
| PESTLE | Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal, Environmental |
| Strategic risk (2 questions) | Is the strategy right? Is it properly implemented? |
| Financial risks | Credit, market, liquidity |
| Stress testing | One input factor at a time |
| Scenario analysis | Realistic scenarios, often from past extreme events |
| Risk appetite | Type and amount of risk a firm will accept to meet objectives (also risk tolerance) |
| Top-down vs bottom-up | Board/senior mgmt (capital coverage, scenarios) vs line mgmt (acceptable occurrences, KRIs) |
| Inherent / gross risk | Before mitigating controls |
| Residual / net risk | After mitigating controls; may not be zero |
| Conduct risk | Firm's behaviour results in poor customer outcomes |
| Mitigation | Reduce impact, likelihood or both |
| BIS risk areas | Operational · credit · market and asset liquidity · funding liquidity · interest rate |
| Asset vs funding liquidity | Can't unwind a position near market value vs can't obtain funds when obligations fall due |
| Interconnectedness | Interest rate/market/liquidity risks rise with GDP growth; operational and credit risks rise when it slows; interactions are non-linear |
| Contagion | Failure spreads to threaten the whole system = systemic risk |
| Sovereign default risk | State guarantees banks but cannot honour the commitment |
| Recovery and resolution plans | Credible recovery actions + orderly failure mechanism |
| GDPR fine | 20m euros or up to 4% of global turnover, whichever is greater |
| Crypto custody | It is about the private keys; hot = online, cold = offline |