Chapter 6 · Investment Risk

11 of 100 exam questions (~11%) · nominal vs real return · compounding and discounting · investment risk types · beta, alpha, Sharpe, information ratio · tracking error · mandates · diversification and hedging
← Back to quiz
Why this chapter matters. About 11 of the 100 exam questions (~11%, medium priority). Investment risk is the risk that the future benefits an investor gave up today's resources for do not arrive, or arrive smaller than required. It sits on top of the credit risk of Chapter 4 and the market risk of Chapter 5. The chapter is heavy on definitions and ratios that are easy to swap. Trap zones: real return has an exact formula (divide), not just "nominal minus inflation", beta measures volatility relative to the market, alpha measures outperformance, Sharpe uses total standard deviation, information ratio uses tracking error, systematic risk cannot be diversified away, non-systematic can, and diversification = uncorrelated, hedging = negatively correlated. The bank follows the Edition 11 workbook with v12 weights.

6.1 Measuring returns: nominal, real, total, holding period

▼

What "investment risk" means chapter summary

Investment is the decision to give up the use of resources now, believing they can create future benefits worth more than their current value. Investment risk is the risk that those future benefits do not materialise, or turn out to be smaller than required.

Clients hand money to a manager expecting more growth than a plain savings account would give, especially when interest rates are low or inflation is high. Each asset class (equities, bonds, currencies, commodities) has its own risk and return profile, and the manager's tool for balancing them is a mix of asset types, that is, diversification. Performance is normally judged against a benchmark, usually an index or a peer group of similar funds.

Four ways to state a return syllabus 6.1.1

Inflation is a general rise in prices, or equivalently a fall in what a fixed amount of currency can buy. It erodes value quietly, which is why it hurts most those relying on fixed income such as bond coupons. The source's illustration: a 1974 US dollar was worth only about 15 cents by 2023.

MeasureWhat it isExample
Nominal returnThe return as quoted, not adjusted for inflationA deposit paying 12% has a 12% nominal return
Real returnThe return after stripping out inflation (growth in purchasing power)12% nominal with 8% inflation: about 4% roughly, 3.7% exactly
Total returnIncome plus capital gains (or losses)Dividends received plus the change in share price
Holding period returnTotal return over the period the asset was held: (income + capital gain) divided by the initial valueAny span, not necessarily one year
Memory hook: nominal is what the label says; real is what you can actually buy. Total return = both parts of the payoff; holding period return = total return expressed as a percentage of the starting value.

The exact real-return formula syllabus 6.1.1

(1 + real rate) × (1 + inflation rate) = (1 + nominal rate)

Rates go in as decimals (4% is 0.04). Rearranged, 1 + real rate = (1 + nominal) ÷ (1 + inflation). The quick "nominal minus inflation" shortcut only approximates the answer. A real return can be negative: the source's example is a 4% deposit with 6% inflation, giving roughly −2%, meaning purchasing power shrinks by about 2% a year.

Worked example: exact real return
A bank account pays 12% a year while inflation runs at 8% a year. What is the exact real rate of return?
  1. 1 Write the identity: (1 + real) × 1.08 = 1.12.
  2. 2 Rearrange: 1 + real = 1.12 ÷ 1.08 = 1.037 (to 3 decimal places).
  3. 3 Real rate is about 3.7%. The rough shortcut (12% − 8%) would say 4%, so if 3.7% and 4.0% are both offered, the exam wants 3.7%.
Quick check
A deposit pays 12% nominal while inflation is 8%. The EXACT real return is closest to:

6.2 Compounding, discounting and asset-class returns

▼

Compound interest and future value syllabus 6.1.2

Compounding means leaving the interest invested with the principal so that interest is earned on interest. The formula is:

S = X (1 + r)n

where X is the original sum, r the periodic rate as a decimal, n the number of periods and S the sum after n periods. The effect looks small over one or two periods but grows large over long horizons. Compounding need not be annual: interest may compound daily, weekly, monthly or quarterly.

Worked example: compounding
$10,000 is invested for four years at 10% a year, compounded annually. What is it worth at the end of year 4?
  1. 1 Set X = 10,000, r = 0.10, n = 4.
  2. 2 (1.10)4 = 1.4641.
  3. 3 S = 10,000 × 1.4641 = $14,641. (The source's shorter example: $2,000 at 10% for two years grows to $2,200 then $2,420.)

Discounting and present value syllabus 6.1.2

Discounting is compounding in reverse. Given a target sum S needed in n years, the amount to invest today is X = S ÷ (1 + r)n. That amount is the present value of the future sum.

This rests on the time value of money: $1,000 today is preferred to $1,000 in a year because today's money can be invested or spent. Interest can be seen partly as compensation to the lender for that time value.

Worked example: present value
You need $14,641 in four years and can earn 10% a year. How much must you invest now?
  1. 1 14,641 = X × (1.10)4 = X × 1.4641.
  2. 2 X = 14,641 ÷ 1.4641 = $10,000.
  3. 3 So $10,000 is the present value of $14,641 four years out at 10%, and the compounding and discounting examples are exact mirror images.
Direction check: multiply by (1 + r)n to go forward, divide to come back. If your present value is bigger than the future sum, you divided the wrong way.

How returns differ by asset class syllabus 6.1.3

The workbook quotes historical annual returns for 1980 to 2011 (an edition-specific dataset):

Asset classEstimated return paVolatility ranking
S&P equitiesabout 7.8%Highest
Corporate bondsabout 6.1%Middle
Treasury billsabout 1.6%Lowest (cash-like)

Higher return came with higher historical volatility, so time horizon is a key factor in choosing an asset class. The longer the time available, the larger the equity share can be; as a deadline nears (for example the start of pension drawdown) the portfolio can move progressively into less volatile assets, accepting lower returns but also lower falls.

Quick check
How should the time available to invest influence the asset mix, according to the workbook?

6.3 The main investment risks

▼

The seven investment risks syllabus 6.2.1

RiskCore idea
Currency riskExchange rates move against you. Two effects stack: the asset's own price (market risk) plus the exchange rate.
Interest rate riskRates move against you; also bond prices move opposite to rates.
Issuer riskThe bond issuer cannot pay coupons or repay principal.
Equity riskIncome (dividends) and capital (share price) may disappoint.
Commodity riskAdverse price moves in an identical-unit asset such as gold, oil, sugar, coffee.
Property riskUnique, illiquid, indivisible assets with subjective valuation.
Fund liquidity riskCannot turn assets into cash in the preferred time without loss.

Currency risk and interest rate risk syllabus 6.2.1

Currency risk. A yuan-based investor buying shares in a US company faces the changing dollar share price (market risk) and the changing dollar/yuan rate (currency risk). Even domestic investing is not immune: a company that earns much of its revenue abroad has earnings that move with exchange rates. The workbook's example is a Turkish white-goods exporter selling in euros: if the lira rises against the euro, euro receipts buy fewer lira, profitability on exports falls, and the price of its securities may fall.

Interest rate risk. Two income examples: borrowing at a fixed 5% for three years while market rates fall to 2% leaves you paying more than necessary; a variable-rate deposit linked to the Fed pays less if the Fed cuts. It also hits capital: bond prices move in the opposite direction to interest rates.

Trap: the Turkish example is about the lira strengthening harming an exporter, which is the reverse of what many candidates expect.

Issuer risk and bonds syllabus 6.2.1

A bond typically pays a predictable stream of interest (coupons) then repays face value. Advantages the source lists: regular fixed income even if the issuer has a bad year (unlike dividends, which come from profits); a range of yields; usually a fixed maturity; and a higher place in the pecking order than shareholders if the issuer defaults. Bonds suit investors who need a secure home for funds, dependable income, or money for a known future expense.

Issuer risk is the risk that the government or corporate issuer gets into difficulty and misses interest or defaults on repayment. Government bonds are sometimes assumed default-free, but guarantees only reduce the risk: governments do default, and this is called sovereign risk. The other main bond risk is unanticipated inflation risk: unexpectedly high inflation erodes the real value of coupons and redemption.

Quick check
Which statement about government bonds is consistent with the workbook?

Equity risk: four factors syllabus 6.2.1

Equity returns come from capital growth and dividend income. Unlike bond coupons, dividends are not compulsory, so income can fall or vanish; capital can fall or fail to keep pace with inflation. The workbook names four specific factors:

FactorKey point
Liquidity riskEase of selling (see Chapter 7)
Growth riskPrices may fall; in a wind-up ordinary shareholders are last in line, behind creditors including bondholders; upside is uncapped
Volatility riskDegree of price swings; of two shares with similar returns, the one with the lower standard deviation gave better return for risk
Strategic risk of the issuerIndustry cyclicality, management competence, financial soundness (an over-geared company suffers more when rates rise)

Commodity, property and liquidity risk syllabus 6.2.1

Commodity: an asset whose units are all identical in the market (pure gold has one worldwide price; oil, sugar and coffee are others). Prices are volatile, often driven by natural events such as harvests. Commodity price risk is the risk of adverse price movement.

Property is unique as an asset class. The features the source lists:

  • Each property is unique, so the market is segmented into many individual markets.
  • Valuation is subjective; there is no centralised market and no continuous reliable price data.
  • High up-front costs, complex legal considerations and high transaction costs on transfer.
  • Highly illiquid: not instantly tradeable.
  • Not divisible: bought in discrete units, so diversification is difficult.
  • Land supply is finite and can be restricted by legislation and planning, so price is mainly driven by demand.

Property-specific risks: location, the effect of use on value, tenant credit quality and lease length. Property-market risks: interest rates affecting valuations, performance of the sector, rental-growth prospects.

Investment liquidity risk: the likelihood of being unable to convert assets to cash within the preferred time without loss. It has two faces: selling for cash (linked to market risk, since an urgent seller may accept a lower price) and using assets as collateral (linked to credit and market risk, since a weaker credit rating means more collateral is needed).

6.4 Measuring risk: standard deviation, beta, alpha, Sharpe, information ratio

▼

Standard deviation as the volatility measure syllabus 6.2.2

Risk is usually measured as historic volatility, quantified by the standard deviation of returns (as in Chapter 5). Returns clustered near their average mean a low standard deviation (low risk); widely scattered returns mean a high one (high risk). It is calculated from past data on the assumption that future volatility will be similar, though past performance is not a guide to the future.

Rule of thumb from the source: for about two-thirds of the time the return falls within one standard deviation either side of the average.

Worked example: the two-thirds range
An investment has an average annual return of 9% and a standard deviation of 4%. Between what values is the return expected about two-thirds of the time?
  1. 1 Lower bound: 9% − 4% = 5%.
  2. 2 Upper bound: 9% + 4% = 13%.
  3. 3 About a 2/3 chance the return is between 5% and 13%, and about a 1/3 chance it is below 5% or above 13%.
Rational investors want investments producing above-average returns with low volatility. Volatility is compared against a benchmark: the closest index, or other funds in the same sector.

Benchmarks and beta syllabus 6.2.3

A fund's return means little on its own: 10% is good if the market rose 5% and peers 6%, poor if the market rose 20%. A benchmark is any sensible standard to compare against. Typical choices are the fund's peer-group sector (for example as measured by the Investment Association), a relevant market index (for example the Hang Seng for blue-chip Hong Kong equities), or, for some funds, a risk-free-type return such as long gilts plus a margin. Benchmarks must be relevant to the fund's market and used consistently; a manager should not switch benchmark just to look better.

Beta measures an investment's volatility relative to the market or benchmark:

BetaBehaviourIf market moves 5% or 10%
= 1Moves in line (index funds should be at or very near 1)Up 5% gives up about 5%
> 1Swings more than the marketBeta 2: market up 5% gives up about 10%
< 1Swings less than the marketBeta 0.5: market up or down 10% gives up or down about 5%

Beta is generally calculated over 36 months of monthly data. Being historic, it can mislead if the fund's strategy or manager changes.

Quick check
A fund has a beta of 0.5. If the market falls 10%, the fund is expected to fall about:

Alpha syllabus 6.2.3

Alpha is the extent of outperformance against the benchmark: the difference between the return the fund's beta would predict and the return it actually delivered. Its weakness is that it cannot tell incompetence from fees. An index fund makes no stock selections, so in theory its alpha is zero, yet many show negative alpha simply because of fund expenses.

Sharpe ratio vs information ratio syllabus 6.2.3

The risk-free return is the rate obtainable with no default risk. A truly risk-free asset exists only in theory, so in practice a short-dated government bond in the relevant currency is used.

Sharpe ratio = (portfolio return − risk-free return) ÷ standard deviation of the portfolio
Information ratio = mean of excess returns ÷ standard deviation of excess return from the benchmark (tracking error)
Sharpe ratioInformation ratio
Excess return overThe risk-free rateThe benchmark
Risk in the denominatorStandard deviation of the portfolio's returnsTracking error (standard deviation of returns relative to the benchmark)
Higher is better becauseBetter risk-adjusted performance; greater implied active management skillSign of a successful manager; outperformance gives a positive ratio, underperformance a negative one
Memory hook: Sharpe compares to cash, Information compares to the index. The denominators follow: total volatility for Sharpe, tracking error for the information ratio.
Quick check
Which pair correctly describes the information ratio?

6.5 Illiquid assets and responsible investment

▼

Venture capital, private equity and property syllabus 6.2.4

AssetWhat it isAttractionsRisks
Venture capitalA type of private equity: cash for shares in early-stage, high-potential growth companies, exiting by sale once successfulTax relief in many countries; potential for higher returns than mature firms; low correlation with standard investmentsIlliquid until the firm is established; the idea may never reach market, giving no return
Private equityEquity in operating companies not listed on an exchange, via capital injection or acquisition; managers often take control or a board seat and may float the company laterPotential for higher returns; low correlationLoss of the initial investment if the firm fails; no listing means less transparency
PropertyDirect property holdingsConsistently positive real long-term returns, low volatility, reliable income, low correlation with traditional and alternative assetsProlonged downturns; illiquidity and high transfer costs make it suitable for the medium to long term only
Trap: these are the syllabus's illiquid assets. The workbook gives all three the same diversification argument: they do not move in step with ordinary bonds and equities.

Responsible investment and ESG syllabus 6.2.4

Responsible investment (RI) began as a niche for investors wanting ethically-defined parameters and has become a much larger share of the market. It is closely tied to ESG: environmental, social and governance factors used to judge a company. The workbook groups the concerns as follows:

LetterTypical concerns in the workbook
E EnvironmentalClimate change, resource depletion
S SocialHuman rights, animal welfare, consumer protection, diversity and inclusion, supply chain and workforce health and safety
G GovernanceManagement roles and structure, employee relations, pay of management and other staff

Illustrations in the source (edition-specific, not for memorising): BlackRock told fund managers to consider ESG factors (announced 2018); a $550m sustainability-linked loan whose margin moves with the borrower's ESG score; a bank ruling out financing of coal mining; ESG assets valued at $35 trillion at the start of 2021. Firms increasingly disclose material ESG risks, and in 2018 the SASB published industry-specific standards for financially material sustainability information.

Due diligence point: because ESG is popular, some companies may market themselves as ESG-conscious only to win funding, so investors need more due diligence on these claims.

Quick check
Why does the growth of ESG investing increase the need for due diligence?

6.6 Correlation, tracking error and the investment mandate

▼

Correlation and asset allocation syllabus 6.2.5

Asset classes do not move together: equities may rise while bonds are stable and commodities fall. Correlations also change over time. Asset allocation is the macro equivalent of diversifying a portfolio: before choosing stocks you first choose the asset mix, by assessing each main asset class in each major region against the world economic, political and social backdrop.

Tracking error syllabus 6.2.6

Tracking error measures how closely a portfolio follows its benchmark index. It comes in two forms:

TypeAlso calledUse
HistoricalRealised, ex post; usually the standard deviation of returns relative to the benchmarkMore useful for reporting performance
PredictiveEx ante; models range from simple equity models built on beta to multi-factor fixed income modelsUsed by portfolio managers to control risk

Index funds should have minimal tracking error.

Memory hook: ex post = after the event, reporting; ex ante = before the event, controlling.

The investment mandate syllabus 6.2.7

The mandate is set by the investment management firm and determines the fund's aims, the limits it must stay within, and its investment policy. It typically covers:

  • the aim (for example dividend income or long-term growth) and any specific strategies;
  • permitted regions, sectors and security types (equities, bonds, commodities);
  • whether short selling is allowed, whether the fund is hedged, and whether and how far it may be geared;
  • the benchmark index to beat (or match, for a tracker) and the maximum tracking error;
  • any other investment restrictions.

To make sure mandate limits are never breached, they are converted into tighter internal limits used to manage the fund day to day. The wording must let the client understand what the fund will do, but should not be so specific that the firm can be sued when performance slips and a detail was missed. Managers need both the discipline of a mandate and the flexibility to run the fund well over the medium to long term.

Quick check
Why are mandate limits converted into internal limits?

6.7 Mitigating portfolio risk and monitoring it

▼

Systematic vs non-systematic risk syllabus 6.2.8

A benchmarked portfolio moves for two reasons. First, it tracks its benchmark's moves because it keeps similar weights; this is systematic risk and cannot be diversified away. Second, the manager takes over- and underweight positions to gain small edges; this adds non-systematic (specific) risk, which can be diversified by holding at least 15 to 20 stocks with low or negative correlations.

Trap: "which risk can be diversified away?" Non-systematic. Systematic (market) risk remains however many stocks you hold.

Optimisation, diversification and hedging syllabus 6.2.8

Optimisation (often mean-variance optimisation) builds portfolios from the right mix of correlations and variances. Mean is expected return, variance is the risk measure. It can be framed either as minimising risk for a given return or maximising expected return for a given risk.

Diversification: a portfolio of uncorrelated instruments has an expected return equal to the weighted average of its parts, but volatility lower than the weighted average of their volatilities. The reduction is "free" because expected return is unchanged.

DiversificationHedging
Relationship of the risksUncorrelatedNegatively correlated (offsetting)
MethodSpread across many unrelated instrumentsTake an offsetting position in a related product, mainly derivatives (futures, options)
CostFree in expected-return termsCost of the hedge; perfect offset is hard and it can add basis, credit and operational risk

Example of hedging: an equity holder buys a put option (the right to sell at the strike price within a set time). If the market falls, the option profit offsets the share loss. The decision to hedge is a trade-off between the risk of adverse movement and the cost of the hedge.

Quick check
For a portfolio of uncorrelated instruments, which statement is correct?

Short selling and risk transfer syllabus 6.2.8

Short selling means selling a security you do not own (it is borrowed) hoping to buy it back cheaper. A short position gains when prices fall, so it can reduce portfolio risk in falling markets. The danger: if the price rises, losses are unlimited, and some regulators have banned short selling in their markets.

Risk transfer: the credit-derivative idea from Chapter 4 applies to portfolios too. A manager may buy or sell protection (for example credit default swaps) on fixed income assets whose credit outlook they are concerned about.

Monitoring, management and reporting syllabus 6.2.9

Many firms run an investment management committee to challenge managers and check monitoring happens. Four areas benefit from monitoring:

AreaPurpose
Peer review (other managers in the firm)Ensures "house view" rules are followed and no unusual risks are taken
Risk review (independent risk managers)Keeps the investment process transparent and challenged
Mandate compliance monitoringPre- and post-trade checks, for example that forbidden stocks are not held
Performance attributionShows what drives returns: asset allocation, stock selection, currency impact

6.8 Ch 6 cheat sheet

▼

All the formulas + distinctions

ItemAnswer
Investment riskFuture benefits do not arrive, or are less than required
Real return (exact)(1 + real) × (1 + inflation) = 1 + nominal; 12% and 8% gives 3.7%
Total returnIncome + capital gains or losses
Holding period return(Income + capital gain) ÷ initial value, over the holding period
Future valueS = X(1 + r)n ($10,000, 10%, 4 years = $14,641)
Present valueX = S ÷ (1 + r)n ($14,641 to $10,000)
Historical returns 1980-2011Equities ~7.8%, corporate bonds ~6.1%, T-bills ~1.6%
Bond prices vs interest ratesMove in opposite directions
Sovereign riskGovernments can default; guarantee reduces but does not remove risk
Equity risk factorsLiquidity, growth, volatility, strategic risk of issuer
Two-thirds ruleAbout 2/3 of returns within 1 standard deviation of the mean (9% and 4% gives 5% to 13%)
BetaVolatility relative to market; 1 = in line; index funds ~1; calculated on 36 monthly data points
AlphaOutperformance vs benchmark; cannot separate skill from fees
Sharpe ratio(Return − risk-free) ÷ standard deviation
Information ratioMean excess return over benchmark ÷ tracking error
Tracking errorEx post for reporting, ex ante for control; index funds minimal
Systematic riskCannot be diversified away
Non-systematic riskDiversifiable with 15 to 20+ low or negatively correlated stocks
Diversification vs hedgingUncorrelated vs negatively correlated; hedges are mainly futures and options
Short sellingBorrow and sell; potential loss unlimited if the price rises
Illiquid assets in syllabusVenture capital, private equity, property
Monitoring areasPeer review, risk review, mandate compliance, performance attribution
Next: Ch 7 — Liquidity Risk. Or jump to the cram sheet.