Chapter 10 · Enterprise Risk Management (ERM)

6 of 100 exam questions (~6%) · ERM definition · link to governance and ICAAP · risks that move together · escalation matrix · data aggregation · firm vs client risk · accountability · ESG · GRC · participating functions
← Back to quiz
Why this chapter matters. The course weights this chapter at 6 of 100 questions (~6%); the Edition 11 workbook itself says about 5. It pulls the whole course together: ERM is the view across credit, market, liquidity, operational and strategic risk instead of each in its own silo. Trap zones: ERM looks at risks individually and how they relate to each other, Basel Pillar 2 (internal capital and liquidity assessment) is the regulatory driver, consistent confidence levels and time frames are needed to aggregate risk, the VaR time horizons differ (market days, credit and liquidity weeks and months, operational months and years), a client's market loss is a client risk, but it hits the firm's fee income, ESG needs a horizon of at least ten years, and GRC is more than buying software. Cross-links: Chapter 2 (capital and liquidity assessment), Chapter 9 (governance).

10.1 What ERM is and why firms need it

▼

Risk management, enterprise risk and ERM syllabus 10.1.1

Risk management is the practice of using processes, methods and tools to manage risks and uncertainties: identify what could go wrong, evaluate which risks to deal with, and implement strategies to deal with them.

Enterprise risk management (ERM) is commonly defined as the process of applying the discipline of risk management to all the risks a firm faces, to understand and manage them not only individually but in the way they relate to each other. Other names: integrated risk management and firm-wide risk management.

Trap: the key words are "all risks" and "how they relate to each other". Managing each risk type well in isolation is not ERM.

What ERM lets a firm do chapter summary

Traditionally separate risk types have separate reporting mechanisms. ERM groups them to show the big picture in a succinct form so senior managers can make balanced, firm-wide decisions. It enables a firm to:

  • define a common understanding and language of risk;
  • aggregate risk information across all risk types (business/strategic, operational, credit, market, liquidity), asset types (bonds, equities, cash, commodities) and business lines (corporate finance, trading and sales, retail banking, commercial banking, payment and settlement, agency services, asset management, retail brokerage);
  • present summarised information quickly and succinctly enough for better decisions;
  • compare the risk profile to available risk capital;
  • use the firm-wide view to define and fine-tune risk appetite;
  • assign limited resources to the areas of most relative risk.

The workbook's ERM diagram highlights five themes around ERM: risk, ESG, GRC, data and accountability.

The Basel Committee's enhanced Pillar 2 guidance expects boards and senior management to: understand the firm-wide risk profile; aggregate firm-wide exposure information in a timely way using easy-to-understand, multiple metrics; define risk appetite considering long-term performance; and set clear incentives across the firm to control exposures and concentrations in line with the appetite.

Quick check
Which best captures the defining feature of ERM?

ERM and corporate governance syllabus 10.1.2

Governance and risk management are first the responsibility of the board and senior management, as part of their duties to shareholders and regulators. Often this is formally delegated to a risk committee that oversees management of credit, market, liquidity, operational and other risks (Chapter 9). That oversight exists in any well-designed process. What ERM adds: because it integrates all risks, those with governance responsibility can see a single view of the firm's risk profile.

10.2 Regulation, sound practice and linked risks

▼

Basel Pillar 2 as the driver syllabus 10.1.3

Industry regulation such as Basel Pillar 2 (the internal capital and liquidity assessment process, Chapter 2) pushes firms towards ERM even if they do not call it that. The assessment requires three steps:

  1. Define and quantify overall risk exposure across all risk types.
  2. Stress and scenario test that exposure.
  3. Compare the results to available capital.

Step 1 is the hardest, and it is exactly what ERM also seeks to do. So a firm that takes ICAAP seriously has a good chance of building an ERM framework as part of that programme.

Memory hook: Define, Stress, Compare. The first step (firm-wide exposure) is the same problem ERM solves.

Sound practice: risks that move together syllabus 10.1.3

Sound practice recognises that operational, credit and market risks are often linked. The workbook's investment-manager example is a chain reaction:

Worked example: one shock, three risks
An economic shock hits markets. Trace how market, operational and credit risk each rise at an investment management firm.
  1. 1 Market risk. Volatility rises, and volatility is an input to VaR models, so the market risk indicators go up.
  2. 2 Operational risk. Higher volatility brings more buy and sell decisions as the firm and clients rebalance, so back-office volumes rise and so does the chance of errors in the process chain.
  3. 3 Credit risk. If market levels fall far enough, some organisations struggle and may default on debt, raising credit risk in any fund holding the defaulting bonds. An ERM view shows all three indicators together, so the links are visible when one starts to rise.
Quick check
In the workbook's example, why does operational risk rise after an economic shock?

10.3 Goals and cultural challenges

▼

Goals of an ERM programme syllabus 10.1.4

  • Design and implement methods to collate firm-wide information on all risk types, asset types and business lines.
  • Enable decisions through aggregated risk reporting.
  • Allow comparison of the firm's risk profile with available risk capital.
  • Set clear accountability and incentives to control exposures and concentrations in line with the stated risk appetite.

Challenges are both technical and cultural. The syllabus names five areas: exception-based escalation, aggregation, accountability, ESG risks, GRC. The following sections take each in turn.

Cultural challenges syllabus 10.1.4

ChallengeWhat the workbook says
Executive sponsorERM needs active involvement from credit, market and operational risk, compliance, finance and others. The sponsor must be senior enough to secure resources, yet able to grasp the detail, and vital in winning acceptance of the new all-risks reporting.
Common risk languageRisk departments use similar but not identical vocabulary, so misunderstandings arise. A firm-wide glossary supports collaboration and helps embed the approach.
Merging risk teamsCombining financial (credit and market) risk teams with operational risk teams is hard because of different cultures and skill types. Leaders need strong people management skills, not just knowledge of several risk types.
Quick check
Why is a common risk language important when establishing ERM?

10.4 Exception-based escalation and data aggregation

▼

Exception-based escalation syllabus 10.1.4

Two kinds of risk information move up the chain: periodic reporting of risk and control information, and immediate escalation of risks as they materialise and controls as they fail. An ERM framework holds so much potentially escalatable information that, without an exception-based approach, senior teams cannot tell what to prioritise.

Solution: set thresholds and limits per risk type, and use them to build an escalation matrix: a table showing potential incident types and who should be alerted at different severity levels. Remaining challenge: major incidents span several departments, and piecemeal escalation from different departments makes it harder for seniors to prioritise and coordinate.

Data aggregation: three inter-related challenges syllabus 10.1.4

ChallengeIssueDetail
MeasurementComparability across risk typesConfidence levels and time frames must be consistent across all measured risks. Measures must allow direct comparison between asset classes: tracking error for equities and duration for bonds have different units. This was one driver of VaR's popularity, since used carefully it gives comparable results across disparate risks.
TimescalesDifferent risks are viewed over different horizonsIntegrated VaR models: market VaR (short term, days), credit and liquidity VaR (medium term, weeks and months), operational VaR from key scenarios (longer term, months and years). Reports are also slow to produce: complex inputs from disparate sources, and narrative must be added so seniors act quickly.
Combining the dataSummarise without double-countingSeparate firm risks from client risks so the risk profile is not inflated (next section).
Memory hook for horizons: Market = days; Credit and Liquidity = weeks and months; Operational = months and years. Short to long.
Quick check
Which ordering of typical VaR time horizons, shortest to longest, matches the workbook?

10.5 Firm risks vs client risks, and accountability

▼

Firm risks vs client risks syllabus 10.1.4

Firm risksClient risks
Who is hit(a) Just the firm, or (b) clients in a way that requires the firm to compensate themOnly the client, with no compensation payable by the firm
ExamplesThe firm's own resources fall in value through credit, market, investment, liquidity or operational risk; or it pays compensation for its errors (regulatory requirement, or voluntarily to protect reputation)A client fund falls because of systematic market risk; markets fall as well as rise, so clients would not normally expect compensation

Indirect effect: even for a client risk, the firm still loses fee income when client holdings fall in value. So the VaR on client funds can be translated into an "earnings at risk" figure for the firm, which belongs in enterprise risk management.

Worked example: classifying a fund fall
A client equity fund drops in a general market decline, and separately a back-office error causes a client loss that the firm must repay. How does each show up in the firm's enterprise risk?
  1. 1 Market decline: a client risk (systematic market risk, no compensation). Not counted as the firm's own loss, so counting it would double-count.
  2. 2 But the firm's fees fall with fund values, so it is captured as earnings at risk (from the VaR of client funds).
  3. 3 Back-office error requiring compensation: a firm risk (operational risk where the firm pays clients), included in full.
Quick check
A client fund falls because of a general market decline. For the firm, this is mainly captured as:

Accountability syllabus 10.1.4

A visible ERM programme raises accountability in three ways:

  1. Departments or named individuals listed as risk or control owners in reports seen by senior managers become keen to do their role well.
  2. If a risk materialises, executives know which department or individual must resolve it.
  3. With clear accountability, other staff know they need not try to fix issues "just in case", so they are more productive in their own areas.

10.6 ESG risks and GRC

▼

ESG risks in an ERM framework syllabus 10.1.4 and 10.1.5

Banking and finance are expected to be fundamentally affected by ESG risks. The transition to a greener economy may bring opportunities, but the sector is also exposed to financial risks from that transformation and from worsening physical conditions. The regulatory framework is being revised to bring ESG into all three pillars of the banking prudential framework, first:

  • Pillar 2: firms' internal assessment of ESG risks and the supervisory review and evaluation process (SREP).
  • Pillar 3: disclosure of ESG metrics and measurements.

Firms must build ESG into strategy, governance and risk management by considering materiality over different time horizons, by embedding material ESG risks into risk appetite frameworks and managing ESG risks as drivers of financial risks, reflected in the internal capital and liquidity assessment. The three ERM steps:

StepWhatExample
1. IdentificationClassify exposures by ESG characteristicsBy asset class, sector, geography, counterparty, maturity
2. EvaluationEstimate ESG risks with methodological toolsScenario analysis
3. ActionIncorporate into business strategy, internal governance and risk managementLimits, KPIs, disclosure

Time horizon: unlike the shorter horizons of credit, market and operational risk, ESG risks require strategic planning to extend to at least ten years, testing resilience under scenarios and disclosing and implementing ESG-related objectives and limits, including KPIs, consistent with risk appetite.

Trap: the ESG time horizon is at least ten years, longer than the other risk types. Identify, Evaluate, Act.
Quick check
For ESG risks, the workbook says strategic planning should extend to at least:

Governance, risk and compliance (GRC) syllabus 10.1.4

GRC is a set of processes and procedures that help an organisation achieve its objectives by harmonising the identification, assessment and management of risk across the company. It spans disciplines including ERM, compliance, third-party risk management and internal audit. Each discipline has its own priorities; GRC adds shared data and intelligence for better results and a more resilient organisation.

Not a product: buying one GRC software system or forming a specialised department will not on its own solve GRC concerns. A robust strategy involves: defining the right objectives; ensuring smooth communication so the right information reaches the right people; and establishing and enforcing the right actions and controls for risk and compliance needs.

Benefits: lower costs, less duplication of activity, easier and faster access to information, higher quality and accuracy of information, and the ability to repeat key processes consistently.

10.7 Business functions in an ERM programme

▼

Who contributes syllabus 10.1.6

FunctionContribution
Strategic planningDistils the external threats and opportunities into currently relevant drivers, with strategic initiatives to address them
FinanceInformation on available capital and future earnings; liquidity risk information may come from finance or, in some firms, the treasury desk
Risk departmentsLiquidity, credit, market and operational risk teams supply the risk information for ERM reporting. The operational risk team may also supply: losses above a threshold, the controls environment, business continuity planning and insurance arrangements
Internal auditPlays a key role but independently of providing risk information: audits the ERM framework for accuracy and robustness, evaluates effectiveness and recommends improvements
Trap: internal audit audits the ERM framework; it does not supply the risk information (that keeps it independent, consistent with the third line in Chapter 9).
Quick check
What is internal audit's role in an ERM programme?

10.8 Ch 10 cheat sheet

▼

All the definitions + lists

ItemAnswer
ERMApplying risk management to all risks, individually and in how they relate to each other
Other namesIntegrated risk management; firm-wide risk management
Risk types aggregatedBusiness/strategic, operational, credit, market, liquidity
Asset types aggregatedBonds, equities, cash, commodities
ERM benefitsCommon language, aggregation, quick summaries, compare to risk capital, tune appetite, allocate resources
Regulatory driverBasel Pillar 2 (internal capital and liquidity assessment)
Pillar 2 stepsDefine and quantify exposure; stress and scenario test; compare to capital
Hardest stepThe first: define and quantify all-risk exposure
Linked risksVolatility up: market risk; more trading: operational risk; defaults: credit risk
Five challenge areasException-based escalation, aggregation, accountability, ESG, GRC
Executive sponsorSenior enough for resources, close enough to the detail
Escalation matrixIncident types against who is alerted at each severity
Aggregation challengesMeasurement, timescales, combining data
Aggregation needsConsistent confidence levels and time frames
VaR horizonsMarket: days; credit and liquidity: weeks and months; operational: months and years
Firm riskHits the firm, or clients so the firm must compensate
Client riskHits clients with no compensation; still affects fees (earnings at risk)
Accountability gainsOwners keen; clear resolver; staff more productive
ESG stepsIdentification, evaluation (scenario analysis), action
ESG horizonAt least ten years
ESG regulation focusPillar 2 (assessment, SREP) and Pillar 3 (disclosure)
GRCHarmonised identification, assessment, management of risk; not just software
ERM contributorsStrategy, finance/treasury, risk departments, (independently) internal audit
You have finished the chapter walkthroughs. Jump to the cram sheet for a one-page review, or go back to Ch 1 to revise.